Interfaith Theologian

Wednesday, October 28, 2015

The Cave Paintings Associated with Jesus and Amaterasu

Ever in search of comparative religious realities, I came across this painting of Amaterasu, one of the founding deities of Japan and a worshipful god in Shintoism. According to the Kojiki, Amaterasu, goddess of the sun, hid herself in a heavenly cave to avoid the wrath of her brother Susanoo. After Susanoo was banished from heaven, Amaterasu emerged from the cave. In the painting below, you can clearly see the radiant beams coming off of the goddess as a rock is rolled away from the face of the cave. Amaterasu is often depicted as the center of the Japanese flag in deference to the Land of the Rising Sun. The cave depiction certainly reminds one of another story…


Amaterasu Emerging from the Cave
Jesus Emerging from the Tomb



Wednesday, September 9, 2015

More Christian Parallels in the Gospel of John to the Jewish festival of Sukkoth


We are once again approaching Sukkoth. In a former post (dated October 8, 2012), I noted why it was important not to rely entirely on the witness of the New Testament since it seems to mix up its Jewish holidays, namely Sukkoth and Pesach (Passover).

Something I neglected to mention, but is particularly important to the argument that Palm Sunday happened during Sukkoth September-October and not on Easter March-April-May (as is commemorated in the Christian calendar) is again from the historic ritualism associated with Sukkoth and the Gospel of John.

Orthodox Jews commemorating Sukkoth with Lulav and Etrog.
In John 12:13-14, Jesus is depicted as riding into Jerusalem on a donkey six days before Passover (John 12:1). The gospel reads:

“They took palm branches and went out to meet him, shouting, "Hosanna!" "Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord!" "Blessed is the king of Israel!"

To take the palm branches (lambanō) only means to carry them out. There is nothing too interesting going on in the Greek here, just the act of carrying (non-violently, it should be mentioned).

Now in the Jewish ritualism of Sukkoth, there is a very specific idea associated with the holiday.  Four species of plants are identified, one of them being palms (lulav).  This, we are told by the Talmudists, is based primarily on Leviticus 23:40

“And you shall take on the first day the fruit of splendid trees, branches of palm trees and boughs of leafy trees and willows of the brook, and you shall rejoice before the LORD your God for seven days.”

Would palms have been readily available on Sukkoth during Jesus’ entry into Jerusalem? You bet! Even the Talmud mentions the waving ceremony known as na'anu'im – נענועים in which participants waved the branches in the Temple. Myrtle and willow were also used, but the bundle was often referred to collectively as lulav. A possible reason why the church retained only the palm branch in its ritualism without the collective meaning implied by lulav was that the reference was most like not Talmudically sourced and was biblically sourced, e.g., temarin used in the Jewish Bible was the Hebrew for palm trees. Because this was also an agricultural festival, there is a sense that the selection of fruits and trees had to do with honoring God’s power over creation. There are movements involved with the Jewish festival. Not so much with Palm Sunday. Had the author of John added that those who went out to see Jesus were waving their branches at him, Jesus might have been stoned on the spot, given the implication. But the crowd does say something just as controversial, and the author of John is no amateur to creating drama in his gospel.

Like John, the tradition of Sukkoth also kept the word Hosanah. Jews today still walk around the synagogue reciting “Save us.” In John, Hosanna is left untranslated as Ὡσαννά. Most Christians read it as a name, and not as an action “save us.” Now you see why the author of John goes far, but not far enough as to be specific, to create the circumstances that will increasing rile the powers-that-be against him.

Like the chicken and the egg quandary, it is unclear if Christians are borrowing from Jewish lore or Jews are taking something from the Christians, namely the word Hosanah and adding it to their own ritual. It is interesting that Tractate Sanhedrin (see my previous post in October 2012) does in fact try to answer the gospel directly on the charge that Jesus was tried and sentenced in one day. Learned Jews were mostly likely not unfamiliar with the stories being told, and so it is not unthinkable that one who heard the word Hosanah incorporated it into the larger holiday. At best, what we can say is that the parallels do not seem coincidental or forced.

Incidentally, Sukkoth’s last day of celebration is traditionally called Hosanah Rabbah (or perhaps best translated as the “Great Salvation” – some translate it as “Great Supplication,” but this doesn’t fully grasp what the word implies).

Hosanah Rabbah is not placed here coincidental to what comes next. On the tail end of this great salvation is the holiday of Yom Kippur, the Day of Atonement. Why is this so important to Christians? Because John’s writer understands that Jesus enters for both the salvation of the people and as atonement for their sins. Between Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur is the time of self-judgment. How perfectly all this fits into the Christian theological narrative of death and life! To have Easter occur at any time other than Sukkoth would be strange, except that this is precisely what the author of John tells us happens! Despite all the ritualism and intrinsic meaning of these three holidays, Jesus is said to enter at Passover. Passover? Perhaps John was just trying to cram as many Jewish festivals into one time frame to hint at how Jesus is the fulfillment of them all, or at least the ones dealing with themes of salvation. In any event, the festival of Passover is likely misplaced. And scholars of this gospel since modern times have faulted John for his problematic timelines as well as the number of times Jesus’ visits Jerusalem. If this is all true, John most likely wasn’t the best timekeeping historian, and the theological, not historical, information was more important. As you think on Sukkoth this year, it might not be a stretch for Christians to do their Easter celebrating a little earlier this year.

Wednesday, September 2, 2015

Ancient Astronaut Theory, Theology, and the Work of Creative Imagining


As our knowledge expands into ever-greater areas of scientific discovery and as we take our search for the elemental foundations of life to the stars, pop philosophies like the ancient astronaut theory (AAT) have gradually prevailed over our popular imagination. While there are some who would hold that AAT is the byproduct of a media generation out of control, it is worth considering how the philosophical musing that bring us to think on the supposed origins (Ursprung) of our religions according to our sacred stories come very close to the way ancient peoples carried on oral traditions, sat around campfires, told stories of anthropomorphic gods coming down to earth.

The sophistication of theological scholarship through which one imagines the person of Jesus, his work, and his life's mission may push to the back the mythologies of ancient humanity in an effort to keep us free from charges of rank superstition, yet at its root, discovering someone like Jesus means discovering the culture of this period, even if theologians like to pretend that the prevailing culture is a transitory or ephemeral backdrop to some greater truth. As an example of this, I remember how William Lane Craig in a speech given to students in England scoffed at the “fantastic and bizarre interpretations of the Church Fathers.” The motivation behind his clarification was an attempt to get at a truth buried by myth. And so in our present day efforts, theology tends to clean up its act much better than the world that first claims to have inherited Jesus’ words. Yet, that backdrop, however whitewashed it has become teases us with a story in which a god come-down-from-heaven inhabits the life of a man. The full force of this fact is difficult to fully subdue in our present secular and scientific age. And so some elements must be retained.

What is left to those in certain circles is to give science the license to explain it all. And that’s where AAT comes in. While the sciences have attempted to illumine the biblical world for us in the last century’s worth of work, whether it be through medical explanations for the blood-turned-water miracle in Jesus’ body, the parting of the Red Sea as explained through tidal and evaporative explanations, etc., a philosophy of science as a narration of the past has unfortunately only taken hold in more popular media. This is primarily because the question of a "truth behind" the narratives or the reality of G-d is not as important, or perhaps credible subject matter, as is the origin of Paul's letters. The goal of science is to give us physical explanations using the tools it has available. Yet a "philosophy of science" stays within the parameters of debunking super-naturalistic explanations with possible natural alternatives.  This should not be confused with the academic discipline, which generally asks questions of ethics or epistemology. So perhaps calling it “philosophy of science” is not wholly accurate. But nevertheless, it adopts meaningful approaches that are built into the scientific language of our day to approach religion. Gods become ancient alien travelers. Temples become shrines not to unseen gods but testaments to the visitation of other-world explorers. Human origins are explained not by the breath of God but by the seeding of asteroids or meteors (a theory known as panspermia). Traveling to another planet, once thought an impossibility (primarily because planets and stars made up the literal heavens) is now, according to the scientific community, within reach. Probe and satellite launches are only a beginning.  
 

Salvador Dali, “Sacrament of the Last Supper” (1955)
Scholarly theology of course attempts to chase out science suggesting that miracle stories, mythologies have to do with the social sciences. Genre issues are important, for example, because a proper reading somehow carries our inquiry to its truer meaning. True scientists, however, do not give ancient people that benefit of the doubt. It is after all, hard to sophisticate a knowledge of God held, for example, by Paul, while many theologians (like our Church Fathers) fell victim to the base superstitions of their day. One such view, held by Augustine, was that the faraway stars and planets were actually demons. Augustine came three hundred years after Christ.  Even Paul, perhaps reading from Enoch, a popular piece of apocryphal literature during his time, though angels might be tempted to have sex with women, and so the latter must cover their heads to repel such predatory indiscretions.

AAT looks at the response of ancient peoples to perceived supernatural, or even paranormal , events.  One such reaction, as mentioned above, was to build temples to commemorate some grand visitation.  Some ancient astronaut theorists assert that Hindus built stupas after seeing the ancient space crafts that transported aliens around the skies. The Vimana in the Mahabharata, for example, are depicted as spaceships that transported the gods around the skies. As further evidence, these theorists point to paintings with strange objects that resemble the kind of witness testimonials given support today. Further, they point to testimony given by actual people. Reports that the Indians of South America thought the white men to be gods are thought to be references to previous encounters with beings coming from far away.  A newer area of interest for AAT is in the capacity of weapons of mass destruction to destroy the world. Mentions to the Brahmastra, a weapon described in the Mahabharata of great destructive force is considered one such example of supposed modern technological efficiency known to the ancient Indus River Valley civilization that should not have been known to them given what we know of ancient people. Interestingly, as a precursor to AAT, the Christian prophetic movement since at least the 1970s has attempted to marry the social situations of our day with biblical verses - and not just political views, but technology that would have the manifest capacity to fulfill the kinds of  world-encompassing events found in Revelation, such as the establishing of a one-world government, a system of applying a "666" number to each individual throughout the world, or even the destruction of the earth by fire as pictured in 2 Peter 3:10, an event thought impossible except for divine intervention, except that today, we now know that a nuclear holocaust has such power.

And what of the building of temples? One such reaction might be in the New Testament. When the Apostles see Jesus transfigured, they want to build three tabernacles in Matthew 17. Jesus rebukes them for it. While theologians might point to the building of the golden calf as a sign of disobedience that may loosely tie this event to the giving of the Commandments to Moses on Mt. Sinai, ancient astronaut theorists, who summon the mechanics of a historical-critical approach into their own philosophy believe that the meta-story behind each of these can be found in the type of event itself. A supernatural visitation, thus, requires the building of something. If Jesus was being visited upon by God so that his true glory was made manifest, a tabernacle or physical structure seems appropriate.  

Late in my graduate studies program in Theology, I did an independent study on the question of the Incarnation and other possible worlds, and found a wealth of material. I read C.S. Lewis, but also other established theologians like Brian Hebblethwaite  (Queens College, UK) and Thomas Morris (Notre Dame, USA). As I continue to see television shows on science fiction and religion or AAT and religion, I think we will find in the days ahead how these areas of concern continue to amaze us with their parallels.

 

Thursday, August 20, 2015

Lost in Translation and the Problem of a Pure Christian Message: How "Christianity" Assimilates and Changes Among Christians in Other Parts of the World.


We all know that the formation of Christianity happened in the Greco-Roman world under the influences of Judaism. Indeed, it is often demonstrated that concepts that are not found in Judaism, such as the gospel of John’s use of the Stoic concept of logos, found their way into important doctrines of the Christian Church through the intimate relationship the Church’s writers had with their own Greco-Roman culture.

Western Christianity regularly forgets that Christianity is a world religion that penetrates many cultures. And when enculturation of beliefs occurs, like the foundational integrations between Judaism and Hellenism, Christianity also never survives an unadulterated introduction into the culture it seeks to entice into conversion. Here are just a couple of examples where the “pure” message of Christianity is hybridized into some cultures that approximate Christianity, but lend new meaning and practice.

Yomi no Kuni is the underworld in Shinto Japan. Unlike Christianity’s hell, it is not a place of demons and devils but a final abode for all the dead, and the place where the primordial god Izanami first went to die after her fight with her fire-god son.  The kanji for Yomi no Kuni (meaning “yellow springs” from the Chinese) is 黄泉.

What is interesting is that when Christian missionaries first took their message to Japan in the 1500s and the age of bible translations flourished in the 1800s, the standard way of representing hell was as 黄泉. So in Revelation 6:8 for example, hell, which follows the pale rider of Death is represented as Yomi no Kuni. I don’t read Kanji (though I took a semester of Japanese in college), but here is the verse in Japanese. The kanji characters that are important are highlighted.

そこで見ていると、見よ、青白い馬が出てきた。そして、それに乗っている者の名は「死」と言い、それに黄泉が従っていた。彼らには、地の四分の一を支配する権威、および、つるぎと、ききんと、死と、地の獣らとによって人を殺す権威とが、与えられた。

The "actual" entrance to Yomatso Hirasaka (or Yomi no Kuni)
A striking and perhaps intentional parallel to Revelation 6 is the return of Christ in Revelation 19 who is followed by the armies of heaven riding on a white horse and dressed in white robes (just as a side note, the incarnation of Vishnu named Kalki is also pictured in Indian legend as returning from the clouds on a white horse). But unlike the angels, these are the saints of God….the believers. Yet the Japanese translation has taken the former understanding of Yomi no Kuni, and narrowed the meaning considerably. Yomi no Kuni becomes similar to a place like Abraham’s bosom (whatever this is) or Hades, where everyone goes, or Niraka in some forms of Hinduism. This is not the vision of Western Christianity, but it creates interesting problems for anyone trying to wrap their minds around the eschatology. Yomi no Kuni as a Shinto concept where all the dead go becomes Yomi no Kuni as a Christian concept where only the evil dead go. Why this happens is up for debate. One might argue those who welcomed assimilation loved to glory in parallels where they could be found, even if they were only approximations.  To find parallels was to create reassurances about the importance of one's own culture in the face of foreign ideas. Precision and accuracy were not as important as the comfort of taking foreign concepts that already had some shape or resonance in one’s culture (“you’ve got an underworld…we’ve got an underworld”), ignoring the finer points of detail, and making them your own without understanding how they “fit” into the larger picture.

When one looks at Hinduism, various ex-Hindu Christians have sought to assimilate their new faith in various ways. One such example is referring to heaven as Vaikuntha. The translation from Hindi, meaning “the paradise of Vishnu” becomes the abode of Jesus (Yeju Krista). Vishnu, of course, is one of the most important deities in bhakti (devotional) Hinduism, next to Shiva. Moksha (liberation) is often seen as the path of spiritual enlightenment, though it is very much part of the religious tradition of Hindu yoga (the four paths of marga) and Samkhya by self-attainment, but also Hindu philosophy, such as Vedanta, where it is reimagined among Indian Christians. As well as offering a means of liberation, Moksha is often equated with the Christian heaven as a place where Jesus is seated.
What is important is that for Indian Christians, losing their own religious verbiage within their new set of beliefs is often a non-negotiable condition. Unless there is specific and perhaps aggressive influence by Western Christians, Indians were permitted to attune Christianity into the natural flow of Hinduism, which is a religious of deep and rich polyphony. Even among the staunchest Indian Christians, like those of the Christa Ashram in Ponono, and excluding Charismatics and some Evangelicals, Jesus is still called Sadguru (or good teacher). Many depictions of Jesus in India place him in the position of sadhana (doing spiritual exercises) or resting on a lotus flower (imagery important to the sacred symbology of Eastern religions). While one linguist may say that Sadguru, for example, is simply a translation for “good teacher,” a philosopher or sociologist of religions might argue that words are often not disassociated from their cultural meanings.  By calling Jesus “Sadguru,” Indians look to keep Jesus in the mainstream of Hindu religious and cultural existence.

These are just some of the ways religious homogeneity remains a difficult task. Assimilations like these challenge a pure understanding of the faith we think we have or think we can recover, despite Paul's hope that we all come to one faith and one baptism. We haven't been able to do that in Western Christianity, and the task in Eastern Christianity is perhaps more difficult.

Thursday, August 13, 2015

Are All Christians Moral Relativists? The Place of Faith in Moral Responsibility

There was a lot of talk about responsibility as a theological category in the last century. Much of this had to do with the changing socio-politics of the time including two world wars that left the religious moral center of Western society in ruin. Responsibility for the first time, especially in the writings of Rudolf Bultmann and Reinhold Niebuhr became a way to reconcile faith with moral behavior. Until then, there had always been the strain of “double activity” in Christianity. When one read Paul he was confronted with the prevalence of faith. However, when one read James or even the gospels, it was the moral behavior and obedience that keyed into the duty of man. Paul was often read uniquely, as more sophisticated of the lot, and whose theology made for more creative responses then elsewhere. James, an epistle that Martin Luther threatened to throw into the Rhine River for what he read as its insistence of a works-based salvation, never garnered as much popularity.

Where responsibility became important was in the conversation on absolute and relative morals. It was argued on the one side that moral absolutes created no requirement for self-investment, one only needs to follow and obey. Yet on the other hand, there was an appeal to faith as an individual investment, in which obedience was not seen as a construct of faith but rather its fruit. But it was nonetheless thought to be stale fruit so long as my faith was not provided a clear path through my works. Faith was invalidated outside of works, and was therefore remanded to “wishful thinking.” One could trust in God about the sickness of a loved one, but again, faith required no personal investment. We could fold our hands, pray, walk away, and leave the rest to God. Of course, such formulas exist, but they tell us nothing about the inner life of the ordeal we so desperately wish to understand.

Theologians of this time sensed that faith meant something more than a secondary function that could only be fleshed out by one’s works or obligations. Moral absolutes simply created no element of self-risk. Without risk, the imperative for faith was unclear. Bultmann made a point of this when he noted that Jesus’ rising from the dead was an inauthentic existential act, provided he knew he would rise from the dead. Jesus could be “obedient to the death of a cross,” but his obedience did not necessarily translate into the need to feel the terror of the grave, a feeling of not knowing where his obedience might lead. Faith was thought to be the missing component of obedience. Jesus’ moral response could only be validated by an act of faith that considered the possibility that he might not rise again.  Only when the possibility of failure existed does faith make any sense. This is precisely why obedience without faith is morally suspect as a Christian concept.

To “not obey” or “go the way of the flesh,” only suggests a problem of behavior. Yet responsibility grasped at the very heart of such disobedience as an existential problem that lined up more fully and more rationally with the Christian belief that man inherited his sin nature from Adam.  

Without a clear formula for obedience however, the charge became that such Christians were moral relativists, which was seen as the greater of two evils. In the case of such relativism, one risked the collapse of revelation, the inconsistency of the biblical witness, and finally the loss of the democratizing appeal of scripture that all men are created equal. If men are equal, then surely the situations as they attend them are no different in the interpretative lens of one man than they are for another.

Perhaps one of the more powerful examples of moral relativism came in the theology-meets-life case of Dietrich Bonhoeffer.  Theologians may have felt that moral responsibility was subject to a context of not very well-defined goals, but Bonhoeffer lived this reality. When Bonhoeffer was faced with the decision of repudiating National Socialism and ultimately conspiring in the assassination attempt of Adolf Hitler, he was faced with a moral dilemma that was based not in interpretation but methodology.  

With the injunction of the commandment not to kill (technically, murder) hanging over his head, Bonhoeffer had to strive for a way past the blockade of moral absolutes and come to an understanding of morality that would ultimately shape his decision in the coming months. His answer was that ethics always occurring when one stands before the “face of God.” This understanding meant that the biblical witness had to be shaped through a different kind of looking glass, one encountered by a cacophony of different instructions and voices to experience how God was speaking to the church today. Much like a Charismatic Evangelical, who believes he is speaking a prophetic word might say that the word that comes to him does not resist the totality of scripture, but is emphasized in a living body of work, Bonhoeffer’s decision to look to Jesus was based upon a similar project. This meant that while one could affirm that absolute harmony of God’s word, since the Word was always ontological, the phenomenology of the words demonstrated that some words regularly manifested over others for the edification of the believer. As a people bound to the book, Christians like Bonhoeffer to Billy Graham, found that in “hearing what the Spirit was saying to the churches,” (Revelation 2:7) did not need to invalidate the body of scripture.

The question of whether one is a relativist depends largely on application ethics and not canonicity. If simply admitted that the canon is, we do not need to be harassed about questions of why it is and what it should have become since these are largely historical concerns. That it did become what it is, and that it has consistently been treated as a multi-colored spectrum of God’s interactions with humanity permits response. And how have the people of Christ responded? With many, many different voices drilling down to differences within the heart of each community, but more importantly down to the divided individual. This is not a lack of consistency. For consistency speaks to systematization and simply a cry to return to absolutism. Consistency, at any rate, lies in the continued engagement with the scriptures.

Monday, August 10, 2015

Reading Jesus’ Transfiguration and the Buddha’s Enlightenment: Supercessionism or Synthesis?


In the story of the historical Buddha, Siddhartha attains a place of enlightenment after intensely meditating under a Bodi tree. Achieving this new level of consciousness about life and the goal of humanity to untangle itself from suffering (dukkha), we find Buddha Siddhartha delivering his teaching to Indra and Brahma.

In the story of the historical Jesus told in the synoptic gospels, he takes his followers with him to the base of a mountain where they observe his miraculous transfiguration. His body illuminates with bright rays of light and the three disciples observe the appearances of Moses and Elijah.

What do both of these stories have in common? Certainly we don’t know the motivations of the writers, but both seem to have apologetic value for their authors. In both accounts, the old gods (Indra and Brahma of the Hindus) and the old harbingers of tradition (Moses and Elijah) are giving their stamps of approval to the newcomer (the Buddha and Jesus).

One way to read the stories is as examples of Supercessionism.

Supercessionism is the theological term used for the belief that the value of the old tradition can only be understood, fulfilled, or accomplished in the new tradition. Both of these stories then show that Jesus and the Buddha are teaching their respective “teachers.” It is the passing of a mantle from old to new, the inauguration of a new type of understanding, a new prophet, a new god, a new king. In any case, Supercessionism is held suspect by those outside the new tradition because it tends to invalidate the ongoing validity of the old tradition. The new tradition is thought to correct something about the old tradition, whether it be its theological content, its trajectory, its audience, etc.

Another way to read the stories is as examples of Synthesis (a term that is replacing the more traditional use of Syncretism)

This is a rather new approach in terms of theological approaches, but suggests itself as one possibility in the reorientation of pluralists and perennialists in our age of common religious interests. On this view, there is no new or old tradition, it is simply the continuation of the old tradition. To demonstrate this, its radical departure in both cases from the old tradition can be explained by the evolutions in the old tradition as part of its very makeup. One might point for example in Judaism to the move from Deuteronomic Law to Wisdom teachings which suggested the introduction of foreign elements. One might suggest that Kabbala as a substantive Jewish movement was influenced by its encounter with Christianity as a result of its strong delineation of heaven and hell and its emanation theology. In this way, the old tradition is “reverse engineered” to accommodate the new and also shows a symbiotic relationship that forms over time. We can see this in less radical attempts to find “the historical Jesus in his Jewish context” by scholars of the last century. Others would claim that in Buddhism we see the veneration of the Hindu deities redefined as bodhisattvas rather than gods. In these redefinitions, the break to redefine oneselves is better understood as a corrective whose sole attempt is not to leave its predecessor behind, but to integrate this knowledge as something recovered that was lost, rather than something completely new, foreign, or uncomfortable. 

In both cases, the Buddha and Jesus inhabited lands, cultural contexts, and a social conscience of a people who could identify them by their behaviors within the tradition. Even if they were saying things that caught them by surprise, the people could claim them as their own. Their languages, concepts, and ideas were not so abusive as to be jettisoned from dialogue with the religious teachers of their time. In many cases, the people recognizing them were not put off by the foreign nature of their agencies. This is an important point and worth considering.

Thursday, July 30, 2015

Why I Spend Time Exploring Other Religions


Soren Kierkegaard once spitefully commented that the "very atmosphere of Copenhagen predisposes one to Christianity." Despite this recognition, he lived and died in Copenhagen, and remained true to his own form of Christianity. Dietrich Bonhoeffer criticized Karl Barth for not expanding his intellectual horizons for lack of travel to other countries where he felt British empiricism would lend itself to Barth's own entrenchment in continental theology. Kant never ventured beyond Konigsberg, yet he changed the world of philosophy forever.

One is predisposed to his religious creed or culture for any number of reasons. My challenge over the past five years has been to back away from those things that come easy to me, while considering as many different approaches to religious reality as possible. I make the points only to point out that  cultivating critical thinking does not necessarily require travelling great distances, though I've been indebted to my experiences in England, Finland and Russia (where I made a point of immersing myself in religious experiences in those countries - my only regret was the Buddhist Temple in St. Petersburg was closed when we arrived). This is why I study and practice (perhaps as a dilettante and nothing more - which some would argue create problems in itself), so that no one will say to me at the end of my life, you didn't consider all the options available to you. You didn't make the effort. You made truth a reflection of your own reality.

Anyone who knows me, knows that I have been all over the map religiously. I grew up as a Roman Catholic, moved through Pentecostalism, the Churches of Christ, a Baptist church here and there, Evanglical Lutheranism, the UCC, and finally an Episcopal church. For those who think the break with Christianity was not significant enough, I also spent time in Mahayana Buddhism, and veered into atheism during my college days. I make no apologies for my experiences. I can't imagine standing in a tradition and exerting one's intellectual efforts tirelessly in its defense, with either little or much sophistication, to prove one has already and always known his way through this life.  One might not be "converting" people in such instances, but it certainly begins to look like apologetics, even if the audience is only as large as the person believing or researching the materials. Modification of one's tradition is not enough. Intellectual honesty is important to me. Emancipation from modification has been and is my path for the foreseeable future.