Interfaith Theologian

Saturday, June 4, 2016

A Christian Reading of the Pratyutpranna Samadhi Sutra: A Seminal Document in the Pure Land Buddhist Tradition


The narrative known as the Pratyutpranna Sutra (Pratyutpannabuddha Saṃmukhāvasthita Samādhi Sūtra) is a well-known document from the early second century CE that came out of Chinese Buddhism. It represents the beliefs and ordinances followed in Pure Land Buddhism, although its most important contribution was the idea that the recitation of the name of the Buddha could translate one to rebirth in the Pure Land Sukhavati, a place of eternal bliss. While Pure Land commonly holds three sutras, the Amida Sutra, the Sutra of Infinite Light, and the Meditation Sutra, to be the most important, none of the three actually synthesize the formulaic recitation that has become identified with Pure Land practices.  Scholars have come to see Pure Land ideology to be a true outlier to the Mahayana tradition of Buddhism that grew out of India and moved into South East Asia. Westerners who are familiar with Christianity or practitioners have often commented on similarities between the faith-driven goal of name recitation, trust, and the quality of salvation that resists the samara of endless rebirths. It is with this second group in mind that I wish to go deeper into the actual document, to read as commentary with the Christian scriptures in mind. It is my hope to draw out some comparisons in the tradition of upaya-kausalya, which, among other things, encourages multifarious readings of a Buddhist text for the purpose of finding meaning in it.


[Those yellow highlighted areas represent the most important and seminal passage that influence the origins of Pure Land Buddhism]



Thus I have heard:
    At one time the
Bhagavān was in the Karaṇḍa Bamboo Garden of the city of Rājagṛha, together with an innumerable multitude of great Bodhisattvas, bhikṣus, bhikṣuṇīs, upāsakas, and upāsikās, as well as gods, dragons, asuras, yakṣas, garuḍas, kiṁnaras, and mahoragas. All were seated in the huge assembly.
    At that time Bhadrapāla Bodhisattva rose from his seat, arranged his attire, and fell on his knees. He joined his palms and asked the
Buddha, “I would like to ask some questions. May I have Your permission to ask them now?”
    The Buddha replied, “Very good! Ask any questions as you wish. I will answer them to you.”
    Bhadrapāla Bodhisattva asked the Buddha, “What
dharmas should Bodhisattvas do in order to develop wisdom, like the immense ocean accepting myriad streams? What should they do in order to acquire broad knowledge and understand what they have heard without doubts? What should they do in order to know their past lives and whence they have come to reborn? What should they do in order to live a long life? What should they do in order to be reborn into a family with a great name and to be loved and respected by their parents, siblings, relatives, and friends? What should they do in order to be endowed with even, comely features? What should they do in order to acquire excellent talents, to be outstanding in the multitudes, and to develop superb, all-encompassing wisdom? What should they do in order to acquire the merit and wisdom required for Buddhahood, to achieve immeasurable awesome power, and to adorn their magnificent Buddha Lands? What should they do in order to subjugate hostile māras? What should they do in order to achieve command so that their vows will never fail? What should they do in order to enter the Door of Total Retention? What should they do in order to acquire the transcendental powers to travel to Buddha Lands everywhere? What should they do in order to acquire the bold valor of a lion, with nothing to fear, unmovable by māras? What should they do in order to realize their holy Buddha nature and to accept and uphold the Dharma in the sūtras with understanding, not forgetting anything? What should they do in order to achieve self-fulfillment, free from sycophancy and flattery and unattached to the Three Realms of Existence? What should they do in order to be free from hindrances and to acquire the overall wisdom-knowledge, never deviating from the Buddha’s intention? What should they do in order to win people’s trust? What should they do in order to acquire the eight tones [of a Buddha] and sound 10,000 koṭi tones? What should they do in order to acquire the sublime appearance [of a Buddha]? What should they do in order to acquire the power of all-hearing? What should they do in order to acquire the bodhi-eye to see into the future? What should they do in order to acquire the Ten Powers and true wisdom? What should they do in order to see, in a single thought, Buddhas from worlds in the ten directions all standing before them? What should they do in order to know that the four appearances of every dharma have no reality? What should they do in order to see in this world innumerable Buddha Lands in the ten directions and to know the good and evil life-journeys of the people, gods, dragons, spirits, and wriggly insects in those lands? These are my questions. I pray that the Buddha will explain to me and resolve all my doubts.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Very good! Your questions are so comprehensive that they are beyond measure. You can ask these questions because you have acquired merit in your past lives under past Buddhas; because you have made offerings to Buddhas, delighted in the Dharma in the sūtras, observed your precepts, and lived in purity; because you have always begged for food, not accepting meal invitations, convened assemblies of Bodhisattvas, taught people to stop doing evil, and seen the equality of all; and because you have always had great lovingkindness and great compassion. Your merit is beyond measure
.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “There is a
samādhi called Buddhas from Worlds in the Ten Directions All Standing before One. If you can do this dharma, you will have the answers to all your questions.”
    Bhadrapāla said to the Buddha, “I pray that You will pronounce it. What the Buddha will now pronounce is all-encompassing. It will give peace to [sentient beings in worlds in] the ten directions and provide great illumination to Bodhisattvas.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “There is a samādhi called Concentrated Mind. Bodhisattvas should constantly guard, learn, and uphold it, never to follow other ways. Of all virtuous ways, this is the foremost one.”

Chapter 2
The Training

The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “If Bodhisattvas aspire to attain this samādhi quickly, they should stand in great faith. Those who train themselves in accordance with the Dharma can attain this samādhi. Do not raise any doubts, even as slight as a hair. This Dharma of Concentrated Mind is also called the Bodhisattva Way Surpassing All Other Ways.”
    [Then the Buddha spoke in verse:]

With a single thought, believe in this Dharma.
Following the teachings heard, think only of one object.
Keep only one thought, ceasing all other thoughts.
Stand firm in your faith, without any doubts.
Progress energetically, never negligent or indolent.

Think of neither existence nor nonexistence, neither progress nor regress.
Think of neither front nor back, neither left nor right.
Think of neither nonexistence nor existence, neither far nor near.
Think of neither pain nor itch, neither hunger nor thirst.
Think of neither cold nor hot, neither pain nor pleasure.
Think of neither birth nor old age, neither illness nor death.
Think of neither body nor life, nor longevity.
Think of neither wealth nor poverty, neither nobility nor lowliness.
Think of neither sense objects nor desires.
Think of neither large nor small, neither long nor short.
Think of neither beauty nor ugliness.
Think of neither evil nor good, neither anger nor delight.
Think of neither rising nor sitting, neither proceeding nor stopping.
Think of neither the sūtras nor the Dharma.
Think of neither right nor wrong, neither grasping nor abandoning.
Think of neither perception nor consciousness.
Think of neither cessation nor continuation.
Think of
neither emptiness nor true reality.
Think of neither heavy nor light, neither hard nor easy.
Think of neither deep nor shallow, neither broad nor narrow.
Think of neither father nor mother, neither wife nor children.
Think of neither friends nor acquaintances, neither love nor hatred.
Think of neither gain nor loss, neither success nor failure.
Think of neither clarity nor turbidity.

Cease all thoughts and be vigilant for a given period of time, never distracted.
Progress energetically, never negligent or indolent.
Do not count the years, nor feel tired in a single day.
Hold one thought, never losing it.
Avoid sleep and keep the mind alert.
Always live alone and avoid gatherings.
Shun evil ones but stay near beneficent friends.
Serve illuminated teachers, regarding them as Buddhas.
Hold firm your resolve, but always be gentle.
Meditate on the equality of all things.
Avoid your hometown and keep away from
relatives.
Abandon love and desire and live in purity.
Meditate on that which is
asaṁskṛta and cease desires.
Drop distracting thoughts and learn the way of concentration.
Gain wisdom from words in accord with
dhyāna.
Remove the
three afflictions and purify the six faculties.
Cease lustful pursuits
and leave sensory pleasures behind.
Do not be greedy for wealth or accumulate things.
Know contentment in eating and do not covet flavors.
Take care never to eat any sentient being [dead or alive].
Dress in accordance with the Dharma, and do not be ornately adorned.
Do not tease others, nor be proud or arrogant.
Do not be conceited, nor elevate yourself.
Expound sūtras in accordance with the Dharma.
Understand that the body has always been like an illusion.
Do
not be engrossed by the
[five] aggregates, nor revel in the [twelve] sensory fields.
The five aggregates are like thieves, and the
four domains are like snakes.
All are impermanent and all are unstable.
Recognize that there has never been an everlasting ruler in one
,
Only convergence and divergence of causes and conditions.
Understand and know that nothing in existence is real.
Bestow lovingkindness and sympathy on all.
Give alms to the poor and relief to the unfortunate.

This is meditative concentration in the Bodhisattva Way, which
Will unfold the fundamental wisdom and elicit myriads of wisdom-knowledge.

The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “One who trains in this way will attain the samādhi in which present Buddhas all stand before one. If, among bhikṣus, bhikṣuṇīs, upāsakas, and upāsikās, there are those who want to train according to this Dharma, they should fully observe their precepts and live alone in a place to think of Amitābha Buddha, who now is in the west. According to the teachings heard, one should also think of His land called Sukhāvatī, which is ten million koṭi Buddha Lands away from here. One should single-mindedly contemplate for one day and one night, or even seven days and seven nights. After the seventh day, one will see Him. By analogy, one sees things in a dream, not knowing whether it is day or night, indoors or outdoors, and one’s sight is impervious to darkness or obstructions.
    “Bhadrapāla, Bodhisattvas should do this contemplation. Then huge mountains, Sumeru Mountains, and dark places in the intervening Buddha Lands will all fall away, not posing any obstruction. These Bodhisattvas will see across without having the God-eye, hear across without having the God-ear, and travel to that Buddha Land without possessing transcendental powers. It is not that they have died here and been reborn there, but that
they can sit here and see everything there.
    “As an analogy, a man hears that in the kingdom of
Vaiśālī lives a prostitute named Sumanā; a second man hears of a prostitute called Āmrapālī; and a third man hears that Utpalavarṇā has become a prostitute. These three men have never seen those three women, but they have heard of them and their lust is ignited. They all live in Rājagṛha, and they have lustful thoughts concurrently. Each of them goes, in a dream, to the woman he thinks of and spends the night with her. When they wake up, they all remember their own dreams.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “The three women I have mentioned serve as an analogy. You may use this story to expound
the sūtras, enabling others to unfold their wisdom so that they will arrive at the
Ground of No Regress on the unsurpassed true Way. When they eventually attain Buddhahood, they all will be called Superb Enlightenment.”
    The Buddha said, “Bodhisattvas in this land can see Amitābha Buddha by thinking intently only of Him. When they see Him, they can ask, ‘What Dharma should I uphold in order to be reborn in Your land?’ Amitābha Buddha will reply, ‘Those who wish to be reborn in my land should think of my name. If they can continue without rest, they will succeed in being reborn here.’”
    The Buddha said, “Because of intent thinking, one will be reborn there. One should always think of Amitābha Buddha’s body with the thirty-two physical marks and the eighty excellent characteristics, unequaled in its majesty, radiating vast bright light to illuminate everywhere. He teaches, in the assembly of Bodhisattvas and
bhikṣus, that dharmas [in true reality] are
empty and, therefore, indestructible. Why? Because indestructible are all dharmas, such as form, pain, itch, thinking, perception, birth, death, consciousness, spirit, earth, water, fire, wind, the human world, and the heaven world, including Great Brahma Heaven. By thinking of a Buddha, one attains the Samādhi of Emptiness.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Who have attained this Bodhisattva samādhi? My disciple Mahākāśyapa, Indraguṇa Bodhisattva, the god-son Good Virtue, and those who already know this samādhi, have attained it through training. Hence, Bhadrapāla, those who wish to see present Buddhas [in worlds] in the ten directions should think of their lands single-mindedly, without other thoughts. Then they will be able to see them. As an analogy, one travels to a distant land and thinks of family and kin in one’s hometown. In a dream, one returns home, sees one’s family and relatives, and enjoys talking to them. After waking, one tells one’s dream to friends.”
    The Buddha said, “If Bodhisattvas hear of a Buddha’s name and wish to see Him, they will be able to see Him by constantly thinking of Him and His land. For example, a bhikṣu visualizes before him the bones of a corpse, turning blue, white, red, or black. The colors are not brought by anyone, but are imagined by his mind. Likewise, by virtue of Buddhas’ awesome spiritual power, Bodhisattvas who skillfully abide in this samādhi can see, as they wish, a Buddha of any land. Why? Because they are able to see Him by virtue of three powers: the power of Buddhas, the power of the samādhi, and the power of their own merit.
    “As an analogy, a handsome young man dressed in fine clothes wants to see his own face. He can see his reflection by looking into a hand mirror, pure oil, clear water, or a crystal. Does his reflection come from the outside into the mirror, oil, water, or crystal?”
    Bhadrapāla replied, “No, it does not. God of Gods, it is because of the clarity of the mirror, oil, water, or crystal, that the man can see his reflection. His reflection comes from neither the inside [of the medium] nor the outside.”
    The Buddha said, “Very good, Bhadrapāla. Because the medium is clear, the reflection is clear. Likewise, if one wishes to see a Buddha, one with a pure mind will be able to see. When one sees Him, one can ask questions, and He will give a reply. Having heard the teachings, one will be exultant and think: ‘Where does this Buddha come from and where am I going? As I think of this Buddha, He comes from nowhere and I am going nowhere. As I think of the desire realm, the form realm, and the formless realm,
these
three realms are formed by my mind. I can see what I think of. The mind forms a Buddha for itself to see; the mind is the Buddha mind. As my mind forms a Buddha, my mind is the Buddha; my mind is the Tathāgata; my mind is my body.’
    “Although the mind sees a Buddha, the mind neither knows itself nor sees itself. The mind with perceptions is
saṁsāra; the mind without perceptions is nirvāṇa. Dharmas as perceived are not something pleasurable. They are empty thoughts, nothing real. This is what Bodhisattvas see as they abide in this samādhi.”
    Then the Buddha spoke in verse:

The mind does not know itself; the mind does not see itself.
The mind that fabricates perceptions is false; the mind without perceptions is nirvāṇa.
Dharmas are not firm, only founded upon thinking.
Those who see emptiness with this understanding are free from perceptions and expectations.

Chapter 3
Four Things to Do

The Buddha continued, “There are four things through which Bodhisattvas can quickly attain this samādhi. First, have faith that no one can destroy. Second, make energetic progress that nothing can deter. Third, have wisdom-knowledge with which no one else’s can compare. Fourth, always work under a beneficent teacher. These are the four things.
    There are another four things which will enable one to attain this samādhi quickly. First, do not engage in worldly thinking for three months, not even during a finger snap. Second, do not sleep for three months, not even during a finger snap. Third, do walking meditation for three months without any rest, except when eating and so forth. Fourth, expound sūtras to others, not expecting their offerings. These are the four things.
    There are another four things which will enable one to attain this samādhi quickly. First, take people to the Buddha. Second, gather people to have them hear the teachings. Third, have no jealousy. Fourth, have people learn the Buddha Way. These are the four things.
    There are another four things which will enable one to attain this samādhi quickly. First, construct Buddhas’ images. Second, copy this sūtra on fine fabric. Third, teach the conceited ones to enter the Buddha Way. Fourth, always protect and uphold the Buddha Dharma. These are the four things.”
    Then the Buddha spoke in verse:

Always believe and delight in the Buddha Dharma.
Progress energetically to unfold profound wisdom.
Disseminate and pronounce the Dharma to others.
Guard against greed for offerings.
Discard desires with good understanding.
Always think of Buddhas, who have awesome virtue,
And see and know dharmas in limitless diversity.
Past Buddhas, future Buddhas,
And present Buddhas, revered among men,
With no
more afflictions to discharge,
Are golden in color and have superb physical marks.
They give firm teachings with wisdom beyond the ultimate.

Listen to this Dharma with an undistracted mind.
Forever discard the way of negligence and indolence.
Never bear malice toward others.
Respect teachers as you do Buddhas.
Take care not to have doubts about this sūtra,
Which is praised by all Buddhas.
Always construct and enshrine Buddhas’ images.
Always persuade others to learn this Dharma
And practice it to attain this samādhi.

The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Those who want to learn this samādhi should respect their teachers, serve them, and make offerings to them, regarding them as Buddhas. Those who see their teachers as less than Buddhas will have difficulty attaining this samādhi. Bodhisattvas who respect beneficent teachers from whom they have learned this samādhi can advance. By virtue of Buddhas’ awesome spiritual power, when they face the east, they will see a billion koṭi Buddhas. In the same way, they will see Buddhas [in worlds] in the ten directions. By analogy, one observes the night sky and sees myriads of stars. Bodhisattvas who wish to see present Buddhas all standing before them should respect beneficent teachers, not looking for their faults. Never negligent or indolent, they should fully train in giving alms, observing precepts, enduring adversity, and making energetic progress single-mindedly.”

Chapter 4
The Analogies

The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Bodhisattvas who have attained this samādhi but do not progress energetically are like those who are shipwrecked midway while crossing an immense ocean on a ship fully loaded with treasures. People in Jambudvīpa will all be in tremendous anguish, concerned about the loss of their treasures. If Bodhisattvas have heard this samādhi but do not learn it, gods will all sadly say, ‘Our sūtra treasure is lost.’”
    The Buddha said, “This samādhi is taught and praised by all Buddhas. Those who have heard this profound samādhi sūtra but do not copy, study, recite, or uphold it in accordance with the Dharma, are foolish. As an analogy, someone gives sandalwood incense to a fool, but he refuses to accept it, saying that the incense is impure. The giver says, ‘This is sandalwood incense. Do not say that it is impure. If you smell it, you will know that it is fragrant. If you look at it, you will know that it is pure.’ That fool closes his eyes, refusing to see or smell it.”
    The Buddha said, “Those who have heard this samādhi sūtra but refuse to accept it are as ignorant as that fool. They defiantly argue that everything in the world exists. Not having realized emptiness, they do not know nonexistence. Alleging that their views accord with the Dharma, they say in mockery, ‘Does the Buddha have profound sūtras, as well as awesome spiritual powers?’ They say these contradictory words: ‘Are there bhikṣus in the world who are like Ānanda?’”
    The Buddha said, “Those people walk away from the ones who uphold this samādhi sūtra. In twos and threes, they say to one another, ‘What do these words mean? Where did they get these words? They must have gathered together to forge this sūtra. It is not pronounced by the Buddha.’”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “As an analogy, a merchant shows a precious gem to a foolish farm boy. The boy asks, ‘How much is it worth?’ The merchant replies, ‘If you place this gem in the dark, its light shines on the treasures that fill up that area.’”
    The Buddha said, “The foolish boy still does not know that this gem is precious. He asks, ‘Can its value be compared with that of a cow? I would rather trade it for a cow. If you agree, it is fine. If you disagree, forget it.’ Bhadrapāla, Bodhisattvas who, having heard this samādhi, do not believe it and make contradictory remarks are like that foolish boy.”
    The Buddha said, “Bodhisattvas who, having heard this samādhi sūtra, believe, accept, and uphold it, and train accordingly, are supported by those around them, and have nothing to fear. Fully observing their precepts, they are brilliant, and their wisdom is profound. They disseminate the Dharma and tell people to teach others, who in turn teach others, enabling this samādhi sūtra to remain in the world for a long time.”
    The Buddha said, “Those fools have not made offerings or acquired merits in their past lives. They have instead elevated themselves, carrying on their slanderous and jealous ways. Greedy for wealth and benefits, they seek fame and reputation. They only want to make noisy remarks because they do not believe in profound sūtras. Having heard this samādhi sūtra, they neither believe nor appreciate it, nor learn it. Instead, they malign this sūtra, alleging that it is not pronounced by the Buddha.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Now I tell you this. If good men and good women give, as alms, treasures that fill up the Three-Thousand Large Thousandfold World, their merit is less than that of those who hear this samādhi sūtra and believe and delight in it. Their merit surpasses that of the almsgivers.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “I now say these words, which will never change. Setting aside those who in future lives will follow evil teachers, if there are those who now have doubts about this samādhi I have pronounced, their merit is not worth mentioning even if in future lives they follow good teachers. These people will nevertheless defect [from good teachers] to work under evil teachers. Why is that they, having heard this samādhi, neither believe nor appreciate it, and choose not to learn it? They disbelieve because they have seen few Buddhas in the past and have little wisdom.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “I have the foresight and foreknowledge of those who, having heard this samādhi sūtra, will not laugh in contempt, malign, doubt, or suddenly believe and suddenly disbelieve, but will delight in copying, learning, reciting, and upholding it. They not only have accumulated merit under one or two Buddhas, but have heard this samādhi sūtra from one hundred Buddhas. When they hear this samādhi sūtra in their future lives, if they copy, learn, recite, and uphold
it even for only one day and one night, their merit will be beyond calculation. They will arrive at the spiritual level of
avinivartanīya on their own as they wish.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Hear this analogy. Suppose someone crushes a Buddha Land into dust, then
further pulverizes each dust particle into more particles. Is the number of dust particles produced from a Buddha Land very huge?”
    Bhadrapāla replied, “Very huge, God of Gods.”
    The Buddha said, “Suppose a
Bodhisattva takes all these dust particles and places each in a Buddha Land. He then takes treasures that fill up all these Buddha Lands to make an offering to Buddhas. His merit is very little in comparison with that of those who have heard this samādhi sūtra and have learned, copied, recited, and upheld it. Even if they explain this sūtra to others only for a short while, this merit is beyond calculation. Even greater is the merit of those who have fully attained this samādhi.”
    Then the Buddha spoke in verse:

If there are Bodhisattvas who seek merit,
They should pronounce and train in this samādhi.
Those who believe, delight in, and recite [this sūtra] without doubts
Have immeasurable merit.
Crushing one Buddha Land
Into dust particles,
One can give, as alms, treasures filling Buddha Lands that are
As numerous as dust particles.
Those who have heard this samādhi
Have merit greater than that of the almsgiver.
Their merit is beyond analogy.

I entrust you all to teach others
To progress energetically without negligence or indolence.
Those who recite and uphold this samādhi sūtra
Have already beheld 100,000 Buddhas.
As for the huge dread at the final moment of life,
Those abiding in this samādhi will have no fear.
Bhikṣus who train in this way have already seen me.
They will always follow the Buddha, never far from Him.
As the Buddha’s words never change,
Bodhisattvas should always follow His teachings
To attain quickly samyak-saṁbodhi, the ocean of wisdom.

Chapter 5
The Four Groups of Disciples

Bhadrapāla asked the Buddha, “Unrivaled God of Gods, if there are those who, after abandoning loves and desires to become bhikṣus, have heard of this samādhi, how should they learn, uphold, and practice it?”
    The Buddha replied, “Those who, having abandoned loves and desires and become bhikṣus, aspire to learn this samādhi should observe their precepts with purity, without any flaw even as slight as a hair. To remain pure, they should dread the suffering of hell and refrain from sycophancy.”
    “What is a flaw in observing the precepts?”
    The Buddha replied, “Seeking form.”
    “What is meant by seeking form?”
    The Buddha replied, “If a person’s motive of observing the precepts for self-
restraint is to be reborn in the next life as a god or a Wheel-Turning King, such a wish for pleasures, loves, and desires is called a flaw in observing the precepts.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Those
who protect their purity, fully observe their precepts, and do not adulate others, are always praised by the wise. They should give alms and progress energetically in accordance with the sūtras. Their resolve should be strong, and they should have great faith and sympathetic joy. Those who serve their teachers as they do Buddhas will attain this samādhi quickly. Those who are disrespectful and readily deceitful to their teachers will quickly lose this samādhi, though they have been training for a long time.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Bodhisattvas who have heard this samādhi from bhikṣus, bhikṣuṇīs, upāsakas, or upāsikās should regard them as Buddhas and respect them without intending sycophancy. Bodhisattvas should never be sycophantic but always be earnest. They should always delight in living alone. Though not begrudging even their lives, they should not hope for others to make requests of them. They should always beg for food, not accepting meal invitations. They should guard their moral integrity and be content with what they have. They should do walking meditation, not lying down to relax. Those who are learning this samādhi should abide by the teachings in the sūtras.”
    Bhadrapāla said to the Buddha, “Unrivaled God of Gods, it cannot be helped that, in future times, there will be negligent and indolent Bodhisattvas who, after hearing this samādhi, will not learn it diligently. However, there will be Bodhisattvas who aspire to learn this samādhi and progress energetically, and we will teach them to follow the Dharma in this sūtra.”
    The Buddha said, “Very good, Bhadrapāla, as I express my sympathetic joy, so too Buddhas of the past, future, and present all express their sympathetic joy.”
    Then the Buddha spoke in verse:

Accept and uphold all that I say.
Always live alone and accumulate merit.
Guarding your moral integrity, do not join crowds.
Always beg for food, not accepting meal invitations.
Respect Dharma masters and regard them as Buddhas.
Avoid sleep and strengthen willpower.
Always progress energetically, without negligence or indolence.
Those who train in this way will attain this samādhi.

Bhadrapāla asked the Buddha, “If bhikṣuṇīs who seek the Bodhisattva Way aspire to learn this samādhi, what should they do?”
    The Buddha replied, “Bhikṣuṇīs who seek this samādhi should not elevate themselves. They should be humble, neither self-dignifying nor self-aggrandizing. They should harbor neither jealousy nor anger, nor greed for wealth, benefits, or sense objects. They should protect their purity, even at the cost of their lives. They should always delight in the Dharma in the sūtras and learn as much as possible. They should discard greed, anger, and delusion, and they should not be greedy for fine clothing or adornments, such as necklaces of gems. Then they will be praised by the wise. They should respect beneficent teachers and regard them as Buddhas, without intending sycophancy.”
    Then the Buddha spoke in verse:

If bhikṣuṇīs seek this samādhi,
They should progress energetically, never negligent or indolent.
Do not follow the mind of greed.
Remove anger and self-glorification.
Do not be arrogant, deceitful, or playful.
Always act in earnest, standing firm in the one faith.
Respect beneficent teachers and regard them as Buddhas.
Those who train in this way will attain this samādhi.

Bhadrapāla asked the Buddha, “If upāsakas who are training for bodhi have heard of this samādhi and aspire to learn it, what should they do?”
    The Buddha replied, “Upāsakas who aspire to learn this samādhi should faithfully
observe the
five precepts. They should neither drink alcohol nor have others drink alcohol. They should not be intimate with women or advise others to be intimate with women. They should not be attached to their wives, nor to men or other women. They should not have greed for wealth. They should constantly think of renouncing family life to become śramaṇas. They should regularly observe the eight precepts in a Buddhist temple. They should always remember to give alms. Because alms are given to benefit others, after giving alms, they should not think: ‘I have gained merit.’ They should have great lovingkindness and respect for their beneficent teachers. When they see bhikṣus who observe their precepts, they should not readily talk about their faults. Having carried out these actions, they should learn to abide in this samādhi.”
   

Then the Buddha spoke in verse:

Upāsakas who aspire to learn this samādhi
Should observe the five precepts without breach or flaw.
They should always think of becoming śramaṇas,
Not greedy for wives, riches, or sense objects.
They should regularly observe the eight precepts in a Buddhist temple.
Neither conceited nor contemptuous of others,
Their minds do not expect glory, nor think of wants.
They should carry out the Dharma in the sūtras, without a sycophantic mind.
Abandoning stinginess and greed, they should give generous alms.
They should always respect bhikṣus and make offerings to them.
They should resolve to take the one training without being negligent or indolent.
Those who are learning this samādhi should act in this way.

Bhadrapāla asked the Buddha, “If upāsikās who have heard of this samādhi aspire to learn it, what should they do?”
    The Buddha replied, “If upāsikās aspire to learn this
samādhi, they should observe the five precepts and willingly take refuge in the Three Jewels. What are these three? They should take refuge in the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Saṅgha, never to follow other paths. They should not make obeisance to gods, nor worship spirits. They should not select auspicious dates. They should not be playful or indulgent, or think of sensory pleasures. Subjugating the mind of greed, they should remember to give alms. Delighting in hearing the sūtras, they should remember to study hard and respect beneficent teachers. Their minds should be vigilant, never negligent or indolent. They should offer a sitting-down meal to bhikṣus or bhikṣuṇīs who pass by.”
    Then the Buddha spoke in verse:

Upāsikās who aspire to learn this samādhi
Should observe the five precepts without breach or flaw.
They should serve beneficent teachers and regard them as Buddhas.
They should not worship gods, nor idolize spirits.
They should stop killing, stealing, and feeling jealous.
They should never say divisive words to incite conflict among people.
They should be neither stingy nor greedy, but always remember to give alms.
They should not publicize the evil, but always praise the good.
They should refrain from sycophancy and sexual misconduct.
They should be humble, not self-aggrandizing.
They should respectfully serve bhikṣus and bhikṣuṇīs.
Those who train in this way will attain this samādhi.

Chapter 6
Support and Protection

The eight Bodhisattvas—Bhadrapāla, Ralinnāga, Gaujata, Naradatta, Suṣama, Mahāsusaha, Indrada, and Harandha—having heard the Buddha’s words, greatly rejoiced. They offered the Buddha 500 fine cotton garments and precious gems, and joyfully served the Buddha.
    The Buddha told Ānanda, “Bhadrapāla and seven others are teachers to the 500 people who are with them. They will uphold the true Dharma, and teach and transform these people accordingly. Then these people will all be joyful, and their minds will be free from desires.”
    At that time these 500 people joined their palms, standing before the Buddha. Bhadrapāla asked the Buddha, “How many things should Bodhisattvas do in order to attain this samādhi quickly?”
    The Buddha replied, “There are four things. First, do not believe in other paths. Second, cease love and desire. Third, carry out the pure ways. Fourth, have no greed. These are the four. Those who do them will acquire 500 benefits in their present lives. For example, bhikṣus with the mind of lovingkindness will never be killed or
harmed by poison, knives or other weapons, fire, or water. Even when a kalpa is ending with the world in flames, if they fall into that fire, it will extinguish, just like a small fire put out by a massive amount of water. Whether kings, thieves, water, or fire, whether dragons, yakṣas, serpents, lions, tigers, or wolves, whether forest phantoms, hungry ghosts, or kumbhāṇḍas, those who, targeting Bodhisattvas abiding in this samādhi, desire to bewitch them, kill them, rob them of their robes and bowls, or destroy their meditation and mindfulness, will never succeed. Unless such misfortune is brought about by their past karmas, things will be as I say, not different.”
    The Buddha
said, “Those who uphold this samādhi will not have ailments of the eye, ear, nose, mouth, or body, nor will they have anxiety in their minds, except for misfortune in response to karmas in their past lives.”
    The Buddha said, “All gods, dragons, asuras, yakṣas, garuḍas,
kiṁnaras, and mahoragas, as well as humans and nonhumans, will acclaim these Bodhisattvas. They all will support, protect, and serve these Bodhisattvas, and make offering to them. As they regard these Bodhisattvas with respect and wish to see them, so too will Buddha-Bhagavāns. If there are sūtras that these Bodhisattvas did not hear or uphold before, they will obtain them because of the awesome power of this samādhi. If they do not obtain them during the day, they will receive them in a night dream.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “I can describe, for one kalpa after another, the merit of those who abide in this samādhi, but still cannot cover them all. I have only briefly mentioned a few essential ones.”

Chapter 7
Sympathetic Joy

The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Bodhisattvas can think four thoughts to kindle their sympathetic joy in order to attain this samādhi. First, past Buddhas [when they were Bodhisattvas] attained this samādhi because of their sympathetic joy, who then attained, through self-realization, anuttara-samyak-saṁbodhi, with full wisdom-knowledge. Second, innumerable present Buddhas [in worlds] in the ten directions [when they were Bodhisattvas] have attained this samādhi because of their sympathetic joy kindled by thinking these four thoughts. Third, future Buddhas [as present Bodhisattvas] will attain this samādhi because they also think these four thoughts to kindle their sympathetic joy. Fourth, I too have sympathetic joy.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “In regard to the four thoughts to kindle one’s sympathetic joy, I will use a few analogies. A person walks during his 100-year lifespan without rest, and he walks faster than the wind. Can you figure out the area he has covered?”
   
Bhadrapāla replied, “No one can calculate this. Only the Buddha’s disciple Śāriputra and Bodhisattvas at the spiritual level of
avinivartanīya can figure this out.”
    The Buddha said, “Therefore, as I say to Bodhisattvas, if there are good men and good women who give away, as alms, treasures that fill up the area
traversed by that person, their merit is less than that from hearing this samādhi and thinking the four thoughts to kindle sympathetic joy. This merit is a billion koṭi times more than that from giving alms. Know that the merit acquired from having sympathetic joy is great.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “Far back, incalculable
asaṁkhyeya kalpas ago, in a remote place lived a Buddha called Siṁhamati, the Tathāgata, Arhat, Samyak-Saṁbuddha, Unsurpassed One, Tamer of Men, Teacher to Gods and Men, Buddha the World-Honored One. At that time the continent of Jambudvīpa was 180,000 koṭi lis in length and width. There were 6,400,000 kingdoms, prosperous and densely populated. There was a great kingdom called Bhadrakara, ruled by a Wheel-Turning King named Vaiścin. He went to that Buddha, made obeisance, and stepped back to sit on one side. That Buddha knew his intention and pronounced this samādhi sūtra to him. Having heard it, the king, with sympathetic joy, showered jewels upon that Buddha as he thought to himself: ‘I should transfer this merit to people [in worlds] in the ten directions to give them peace.’
    “After Siṁhamati Buddha entered
parinirvāṇa, the king Vaiścin died. He was reborn in his own family and became the crown prince called Brahmada. At that time there was a bhikṣu called Jewel, who was pronouncing this samādhi sūtra to his four groups of disciples. Brahmada heard of it, and sympathetic joy arose in him. Exuberantly he took jewels worth hundreds of koṭis of great price and showered them upon that bhikṣu, and also offered him fine clothing. Resolved to seek the Buddha Way, together with 1,000 people, Brahmada became a śramaṇa under that bhikṣu. To hear this samādhi sūtra, he and the 1,000 people served their teacher tirelessly for 8,000 years. Because of hearing this samādhi sūtra, though only once, and thinking the four thoughts that kindled his sympathetic joy, he acquired excellent knowledge. For this reason, he subsequently saw 68,000 Buddhas. From each of these Buddhas, he heard this samādhi sūtra again. Through self-realization, he has become a Buddha called Tilavida, the Samyak-Saṁbuddha, Unsurpassed One, Tamer of Men, Teacher to Gods and Humans, Buddha the World-Honored One. Those 1,000 bhikṣus have also attained samyak-saṁbodhi, and all of them are called Tilajuṣa. They have taught innumerable people to seek Buddha bodhi.”
    The Buddha asked Bhadrapāla, “After hearing this samādhi sūtra, who would not have sympathetic joy? Who would rather not learn, uphold, and recite it, and explain it to others?”
    The Buddha said, “Those who abide in this samādhi will quickly attain Buddhahood. The merit acquired from only hearing it is incalculable. Much greater is the merit acquired from learning and upholding it. One should seek this samādhi teaching even if it is 100 or 1,000 lis away. How can one not seek to learn it when it is close by? Those who, having heard of this samādhi, aspire to learn and uphold it, should serve their teachers for ten years, paying visits and making offerings, which they dare not use for themselves. They should follow their teachers’ teachings and always remember their kindness.”
    The Buddha said, “Therefore, I tell you this. If one travels 4,000 lis to hear this samādhi sūtra, one’s merit is incalculable even if one fails to hear it. Why? Because, with such motivation to make energetic progress, one will attain Buddhahood through self-realization.”

Chapter 8
Utmost Sincerity

The Buddha said, “In the distant past, there was a Buddha called Sacanama, the Samyak-Saṁbuddha, Unsurpassed One, Teacher to Gods and Men, Buddha the World-Honored One. At that time there lived a bhikṣu named Halan. After that Buddha entered parinirvāṇa, that bhikṣu upheld this samādhi sūtra. At that time I was a king, in the kṣatriya caste, and I heard of this samādhi sūtra in a dream. Upon waking, I immediately went to that bhikṣu and became a śramaṇa under him. For the sake of hearing this samādhi sūtra, I served that teacher for 36,000 years. However, I was unable to hear it because time and again māra matters arose.”
    The Buddha told the bhikṣus, bhikṣuṇīs, upāsakas, and upāsikās: “Hence I tell you all to learn this samādhi as soon as possible, never to lose it. You should properly serve your teacher and uphold this samādhi sūtra for one kalpa, 100 kalpas, or even 100,000 kalpas, never negligent or indolent. You should stay with a beneficent teacher and never leave him. Do not begrudge food, drink, life-supporting goods, clothing, bedding, beds, or precious jewels. If you do not have any, you should beg for food and offer it to your teacher. Work tirelessly to attain this samādhi. You should even cut off your own flesh to offer to your beneficent teacher, not to mention giving precious things. Serve your beneficent teacher, like a slave serving a great family. Those who seek this samādhi should act in this way.
    “Having attained this samādhi, one should abide in it and always remember the kindness of one’s teacher. This samādhi sūtra is hard to encounter. There are those who seek for 100,000 kalpas but cannot even hear the name of this samādhi. How could anyone who has learned it not progress diligently? If there are those who give, as alms, treasures filling Buddha Lands as numerous as the sands of the Ganges, they cannot be compared with one who is learning this samādhi or one who has attained it, is progressing energetically, and is teaching it to others.”
    The Buddha told Bhadrapāla, “If there are those who aspire to learn this samādhi, they need to have sympathetic joy in order to succeed. Students are enabled to learn it by virtue of Buddhas’ awesome spiritual power. They should copy this samādhi sūtra on fine fabric, consecrate the copies with the Buddha Seal, and make offerings. What is the Buddha Seal? It refers to freedom from deluded states—no greed, no quest, no perception, no attachment, no wish for rebirth, no intended life form for rebirth, no grasping, no concern, no abiding, no
obstruction, no bondage, no existence, no desire, no birth, no death, no destruction, and no decay. This seal is the essence and the root of bodhi. It is beyond Arhats and Pratyekabuddhas, not to mention fools. This seal is the Buddha Seal.”
    The Buddha said, “As I now pronounce this samādhi, 1,800 koṭi gods, asuras, spirits, dragons, and their retinues have entered the holy stream,
becoming Srotāpannas, and 800 bhikṣus and 500 bhikṣuṇīs have become Arhats. Ten thousand Bodhisattvas have attained this samādhi, realizing that dharmas have no birth. Twelve thousand Bodhisattvas have attained the spiritual level of no regress.”
    The Buddha told the bhikṣus Śāriputra and Maudgalyāyana, as well as Bhadrapāla Bodhisattva and others: “I sought bodhi for uncountable kalpas, and I now have attained Buddhahood. I uphold this sūtra and entrust it to you all. Study and recite it, uphold and guard it, and do not forget or lose it. If there are those who aspire to learn it, you should teach them completely in accordance with the Dharma. You should pronounce it fully to those who wish to hear it.”
    After the Buddha pronounced this sūtra, Bhadrapāla Bodhisattva and the bhikṣus Śāriputra, Maudgalyāyana, and Ānanda, as well as gods, asuras, dragons, spirits, and their retinues, greatly rejoiced. They made obeisance to the Buddha and departed.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Good master, what must I do to inherit eternal life? (Mark 10:17; Luke 18:18; Matthew 19:16)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lord, I believe. Help my unbelief.”  Mark 9:24





“Dear woman, said Jesus. “Your faith is great. Your request is granted.” Matthew 15:28

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
"Truly I tell you, if anyone says to this mountain, 'Go, throw yourself into the sea,' and does not doubt in their heart but believes that what they say will happen, it will be done for them. – Mark 11:23

 

 

 

 

 

 





Finally, brothers and sisters, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable--if anything is excellent or praiseworthy--think about such things. – Philippians 4:8

Casting down imaginations, and every high thing that exalteth itself against the knowledge of God, and bringing into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ. – 2 Corinthians 10:5

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Put a knife to your throat if you are given to gluttony. – Proverbs 23:2

 


Your beauty should not come from outward adornment, such as elaborate hairstyles and the wearing of gold jewelry or fine clothes. – 1 Peter 3:3

Pride goes before destruction, and haughtiness before a fall. – Proverbs 16:18

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Get rid of all bitterness, rage and anger, outcry and slander, along with every form of malice. Be kind and tender-hearted to one another, forgiving each other just as in Christ God forgave you. – Ephesians 4:31-32





Give to the one who asks you, and do not turn away from the one who wants to borrow from you. – Matthew 5:42

 

 

 

 

 

We all stumble in many ways. Anyone who is never at fault in what they say is perfect, able to keep their whole body in check. – James 3:2

 

 

Therefore, since you have been raised with Christ, strive for the things above, where Christ is seated at the right hand of God. Set your minds on things above, not on earthly things. – Colossians 3:1-2

 

 

 













Truly I tell you, if you have faith as small as a mustard seed, you can say to this mountain, 'Move from here to there,' and it will move. Nothing will be impossible for you." – Matthew 17:20

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



Salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given to mankind by which we must be saved. – Acts 4:12

 

 

 

 

 

 

And he took bread, gave thanks and broke it, and gave it to them, saying, "This is my body given for you; do this in remembrance of me." – Luke 22:19

 

 

 

 

 

For truly I tell you, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. – Matthew 5:18

Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will never pass away. – Matthew 24:35

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Such a person is double-minded and unstable in all they do. – James 1:8

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Blessed are the pure in heart, for they will see God. – Matthew 5:8

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ask and it will be given to you; seek and you will find; knock and the door will be opened to you – Matthew 7:7

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I do not understand what I do. For what I want to do I do not do, but what I hate I do. – Romans 7:15

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit - Matthew 28:19

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Rejoice in the Lord always. I will say it again: Rejoice! – Philippians 4:4

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

But now you also, put them all aside: anger, wrath, malice, slander, and abusive speech from your mouth. – Colossians 3:8

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Have confidence in your leaders and submit to their authority, because they keep watch over you as those who must give an account. Do this so that their work will be a joy, not a burden, for that would be of no benefit to you. – Hebrews 13:17

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

And He told them many things in parables, saying, “A farmer went out to sow his seed. As he was sowing, some seeds fell along the path, and the birds came and devoured them. Some fell on rocky ground, where they did not have much soil. They sprang up quickly, because the soil was shallow. But when the sun rose, the seedlings were scorched, and they withered because they had no root. Other seeds fell among the thorns, which grew up and choked the seedlings. Still other seeds fell on good soil and produced a crop—a hundredfold, sixtyfold, or thirtyfold. He who has ears, let him hear. – Matthew 13:3-9

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

On hearing it, many of his disciples said, "This is a hard teaching. Who can accept it?" – John 6:60

"Why does this fellow talk like that? He's blaspheming! Who can forgive sins but God alone?" – Mark 2:7

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Nevertheless, many of the leaders believed in Him; but because of the Pharisees they did not confess Him, for fear that they would be put out of the synagogue. For they loved praise from men more than praise from God.  – John 12:42-43

The Pharisees, who were lovers of money, heard all of this and were scoffing at Jesus. So He said to them, “You are the ones who justify yourselves before men, but God knows your hearts. For what is prized among men is detestable before God – Luke 16:14-15

If I give all I possess to the poor and give over my body to hardship that I may boast, but do not have love, I gain nothing. – 1 Corinthians 13:3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Where, then, is boasting? It is excluded. On what principle? On that of works? No, but on that of faith. For we maintain that a man is justified by faith apart from works of the Law. – Romans 3:27-28

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Therefore, since the children have flesh and blood, He too shared in their humanity, so that by His death He might destroy him who holds the power of death, that is, the devil, and free those who all their lives were held in slavery by their fear of death. – Hebrews 2:14-15

Philip said to Him, “Lord, show us the Father, and that will be enough for us.” 9Jesus replied, “Philip, I have been with you all this time, and still you do not know Me? Anyone who has seen Me has seen the Father. John 14:8

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Are you pledged to a woman? Do not seek to be released. Are you free from such a commitment? Do not look for a wife. - 1 Corinthians 7:27 

 

 

Whoever speaks on their own does so to gain personal glory, but he who seeks the glory of the one who sent him is a man of truth; there is nothing false about him. - John 7:18

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Jesus answered, "I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me. - John 14:6 

 

 

 

 

Do your best to present yourself to God as one approved, a worker who does not need to be ashamed and who correctly handles the word of truth.  - 2 Timothy 2:15 

For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in.  - Matthew 25:35 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The tongue also is a fire, a world of evil among the parts of the body. It corrupts the whole body, sets the whole course of one's life on fire, and is itself set on fire by hell. - James 3:6

Love must be sincere. Hate what is evil; cling to what is good. – Romans 12:9

Flee from sexual immortality – 1 Corinthians 6:18-20 

 

 

 

Since, then, you have been raised with Christ, set your hearts on things above, where Christ is, seated at the right hand of God. 2 Set your minds on things above, not on earthly things. - Colossians 3:1-2

 

This sixth chapter is very similar in general detail to the passing of the Buddha, his parinirvana. In translations of the Maha Parinibbanna Sutta, the final hours of the Buddha also occur in the sixth section.

 

 

 

After that, he appeared to more than five hundred of the brothers and sisters at the same time, most of whom are still living, though some have fallen asleep. - 1 Corinthians 15:6

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

And these signs will accompany those who believe: In my name they will drive out demons; they will speak in new tongues; they will pick up snakes with their hands; and when they drink deadly poison, it will not hurt them at all; they will place their hands on sick people, and they will get well. – Mark 16:17-18


 


For I am convinced that neither death nor life, neither angels nor principalities, neither the present nor the future, nor any powers, neither height nor depth, nor anything else in all creation, will be able to separate us from the love of God that is in Christ Jesus our Lord.  Romans 8:38-39

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 

 

 

 



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 









Consequently, faith comes from hearing the message, and the message is heard through the word about Christ. - Romans 10:17 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 




Friday, May 27, 2016

The Transformation of the Christian Funeral and the Declining Influence of Tradition


Funerary practices differ greatly even within larger religious traditions like Christianity. What happens to the body has traditionally been linked to sacred scripture and interpretation, but also cultural influences.

For much of Christian history, cremation was not an alternative for Christians. And in a nation that is largely Christian, 2015 marks the first time cremation has surpassed traditional burial/internment in the United States.

One thing that is true for both Christianity and Buddhism is the idea that funerary practices go back to the examples provided by their leaders and the events surrounding their deaths. Christians have been buried believing that the resurrection of the body, a formal and inveterate doctrine of Christianity, extends beyond Christ to believers as well. Though the idea of life beyond the grave differs in places even in the scriptures, the generally agreement is that believers united to Christ do not do so metaphorically or spiritually, but in their bodies. If the life of the body after death is of importance, than naturally Christians would go through great pains to get it right. Cremation was not allowed because it was seen as a desecration of the body. God needed the body parts pretty much in tact if he was going to raise that same body from the dead to its final glorification. This strong conviction about the body no doubt propels us in other areas, not to mention the prohibition against abortion. The body is something to be honored. Even martyrdoms, an extreme reaction to external challenges to the faith, were not upended by the death of their bodies. Enemies from warring Christian denominations participating in both the execution of Christians in pogroms or on the battlefield regularly dismembered the bodies knowing that the theological implications would be devastating for the victim (i.e., the possible dismemberment meant that the body could not be reassembled). Of course, decomposition was always known to them and so it was thought that the power of the holy person was in their bones. Like the valley in Ezekiel, the flesh could be reconstituted to the body…but if the bones were scattered, maybe not. Having the body remain intact was so important that an early Christian apologist Justin Martyr in a short tract wondered if Christians were regenerated in the heavenly realm with their reproductive parts and belly buttons! The location of burial was also important in some cultures but has largely been abandoned, having ceded to the more important demand for bodily burial. If a person was buried facing the wrong way, it was thought that they could miss the resurrection having their bodies turned backwards!

The easing of restrictions against cremation has perhaps been the biggest and most silent of all changes among Christians in the modern era. In 1964, the Roman Catholic Church "lifted" its ban on cremation, though it never formally elevated the practice to the same level of moral value as burials. In most cases where cremation is preferred, the ashes are still expected to be entombed or buried. This changing attitude towards burial may be attributed to growing secularism. Many people who claim Christianity simply are not linked to a church. Not being linked to church means there is no authority or oversight on these questions, or even concern. When unchurched Christians die, having no relationship with a church or a priest, it is often left to the family who might contact a local parish or church. These priests can preside over cremations, a fact that might be overlooked due to the fact that the priest does not know the individual personally, but nevertheless sees his role as a comforter rather than doctrinal scholar. A second influence that cannot be overlooked is economic. The cost of a funeral, including the casket, internment, church fees, wake, and post-funeral luncheon can be thousands of dollars. For those who cannot afford a burial, the tremendous pressure to honor the recently passed may lead them to other alternatives given the financial burden of burial. Cremation remains popular today because it is less expensive than burial. As money has for most of our religious history proven an equalizer against religious war; so it might be blamed here for the potential to overlook the doctrinal demands that prepare us for the Christian afterlife. And why not have a cremation? After all, an omnipotent god should have no problem reconstituting the body regardless if it has been spread over the sea or digested by wild animals.

Looking to our neighbors in the East, cremation in Buddhism has been around for more than two millennia, although it was interrupted for about 400 years, a movement led by Confucians who opposed cremation. In Japan, over 98% of the population is cremated today. This includes Japanese Christians as well. Though cremation is a cultural norm, the same has its origin in the literature of Buddhism. In the Mahaparinibanna Sutra, the historical Buddha is eventually cremated after an extended panegyric with his faithful follower Ananda. From the prior textual evidence, the meaning of this act is obvious: true Buddhahood is open and available to all and the body is only a transitory vehicle in samsara. The body that one seeks is the ultimate elevation of awakening and pure consciousness, what is known as the dharmakaya, the truth body. The monks are encouraged to cultivate reproach for the physical body and its functions, but not to the point of over-indulgence, asceticism, or self-immolation. This is called the middle way in Buddhism. The body is burned in this final act to demonstrate this ideology.


Buddhists gather around for a cremation ceremony in South Korea.
In Japan, the economy also drives the practicality of cremation. Space is very limited and funerals are expensive. Cremation on the other hand is not expensive. Cremated remains are easily transportable and a space-saving alternative. These arguments were forceful promulgated by advocates of cremation after the 1873 Tokyo ban. The argument was not made from Buddhism at the time, however, but instead that cremation adverted a public health crisis by preventing epidemic spreads of diseases, bodies took up too much space, and the ancestral separation of bodies (which would happen as space ran out) was a moral outrage. Advocates also looked to the West. Research in Europe suggested that cremation was a more sanitary way of disposing of bodies than burial for the sake of public health. Such factors may very well influence the way Japanese Christians ultimately find themselves conceding to cultural practices. But just like other influences that have come to us through secular society, the interpenetration between religion and culture remains. Burial no doubt is rapidly being lost on this present generation as an extension of doctrine, given that doctrine is rarely a concern in the modern liturgy (the outlet through which most people consume their faith), and Christianity in the West finds itself increasingly conceding to the dogmatism of an open culture that is increasingly suspicious of claims to authority.  

Monday, May 23, 2016

The Translation of the Bizarre Term “Loving-Kindness” in Christianity and Buddhism


“Thy loving-kindness is greater than life, O Lord…”

It was a verse from a song I remember well in my early days of navigating the religious landscape of the Evangelical Church. It was one of those songs with multiple renditions, sung by numerous peoples and appearing on worship albums throughout the land so that no one could claim it as their own. The verse itself comes from Psalm 63:3 in the Bible. I never thought much about it. Not knowing its origins, I simply assumed “loving” was added to “kindness” to amplify how much the Lord thinks on us as his creation.

I discovered the word again years later in my readings in Buddhism. Where I first assumed the word something of an anomaly in Christianity, one of many encomiums heaping praise on God, in Buddhism the use of the two-word term seemed much more intentional, if not systematic. Judaism has also tried to co-opt this word, but it seems almost anachronistic given the word's origination as we will see moving forward.

Of course I tried the dictionary first. Maybe I had missed something all these years.  So where does loving kindness come from and why did the translators decided on such a strange word?

In the case of Christianity, we have an easier answer, one that is documented to around the 16th century. Miles Coverdale, in looking for a word to convey the difficult meaning of the Hebrew word chesed decided on the meaning “loving-kindness.” Other translations for the word include simply “kindness” but also “covenant.” We do have a better word for covenant in the Hebrew, bereth, and there seems to be at least some indication that it might be etymologically linked to bara (to cut). So too there is at least one instance in the context of the Hebrew Bible where a case for “covenant” might be made that uses chesed.  Here we see the word kerath – to cut. This word almost always appears with respect to covenant (bereth). The formulaic structure accompanying this word (to cut covenant) is usually not far behind.  The meaning of the cutting of covenant comes from the ritual exercise of cutting a beast in two parts and walking between the two pieces, a strange ritual that was said to have been undertaken by Abraham and God.

If loving-kindness is a neologism that comes about in the last four hundred years, my question becomes all the more urgent: Why would translators in two different religious traditions chose a word so similar?

Buddhist scholars also recognize that the Pali word metta often translated as loving-kindness is likewise difficult to translate. The word metta comes from two roots in Pali – one suggests to be “gentle” and the other is for “friend” (mitra).

It is difficult to track down loving-kindness and its link to metta. We have “love” as a proposed translation, as do we have “friendship.”  But loving-kindness is so far off the beaten path. It’s a word one does not find in the dictionary or in any reliable context that finds its way into the regular nomenclature of secular English. Was it perhaps borrowed from the English translation of the Christian God’s loving-kindness shown towards his followers. Could an early Buddhist translator have picked up a Christian Bible, saw this word, and thought that it demonstrated the same notion of Buddhist compassion? It’s worth thinking about. We certainly know that translated words move indiscriminately from culture to culture. When hell moved in the Japanese culture and certain Japanese Bibles picked up on the word, the translation reflected a entrenchment in cultural Shintoism that was itself a translation from the Chinese for “yellow spring.” That phrase was “Yomi no Kuni” for the land of the dead.

My admission here is that I don’t know how loving-kindness because the translated phrase of choice for metta in English. My theory, however, stands that it most likely had to do with words that were picked from the culture, and it may have been that a well-meaning translator looking for the precision of an English word that would not suggest physical love or simply friendship, or even compassion, decided that loving kindness was a much more visceral word. In such cases, this example amply demonstrates the problems with elevating translations of religious concepts into second or third languages with the task of trying to adduce comparative meaning only through those translations, rather than going to back to the sources that may affirm or deny the usefulness of such exercises.

Tuesday, May 17, 2016

The Two Heavenly Visions of Rajagriha and Jerusalem: A Buddhist Sutta and a Christian Apocalypse

The Sutra of Golden Light is a latter stage document that tells of the existence of other buddhas in addition to Siddhartha, the historical Buddha. These "victor buddhas" are set up as protectors to defend the holy city of Rajagriha.




In the folklore of Eastern religions, Rajagriha is an axis mundi (center of the universe) much like Jerusalem is to Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. In Rajagriha, we have stories of the historic Buddha and the Jain messiah Mahavira living here for some time. The first Buddhist council, a congregation of 500 monks are said to have met here in a cave after the Buddha's death to verify which teachings were authentic. As a side note, the 500 number always struck me. There is no known correlate in gematria or numerology for the importance of this number-value in antiquity in ancient cultures. Yet it is the same number of witnesses said to attest to the authenticity of Jesus' resurrection according to Saint Paul.




What is interesting in the Sutra of Golden Light is the vision had by the bodhisattva Ruciraketu. According to the sutra, he envisions Rajagriha as a great palace. In the  following passage, the details stand out and are worth considering before we move into a familiar Christian text.




Then, while this sublime being entertained such thoughts with regard to the Buddha, his house transformed into a vast and expansive palace made of lapis lazuli, embellished with numerous divine jewels, its color transformed by the Tathagata and filled with perfumes surpassing those of the gods. Inside, in the four directions, there emerged four thrones made of divine jewels. These thrones came to be covered with mats of divine jewels and fine cotton raiment; and on those thrones appeared divine lotuses adorned with numerous jewels, their color transformed by the Tathagata. From those lotuses arose four Transcendent Victor Buddhas. In the east appeared the Tathagata Akshobhya; in the south appeared the Tathagata Ratnaketu; in the west appeared the Tathagata Amitayus; and in the north appeared the Tathagata Dundubhisvara. At the very moment these buddha lords appeared on those lion thrones, the great city of Rajagriha was filled with bright lights. The lights pervaded all the triple-thousand, great thousand world systems, the world systems in the ten directions, world systems as many as the grains of sand in the Ganges river. In addition, divine flowers rained down and divine music resounded. Through the power of the Buddha, all sentient beings in the triple thousand great thousand worlds too became possessed of the joy of the gods. Beings whose senses were incomplete became possessed of complete senses; beings blind from birth saw forms with the eyes; deaf beings heard sounds with the ears; insane beings regained their sanity; distracted beings became focused; naked beings became clothed in garments; hungry beings became full- bellied; thirsty beings were quenched; beings afflicted with diseases became free of disease; beings whose bodily organs were defective became possessed of complete organs. Many astounding events took placed in the world.




What we have here are heavenly buddhas enthroned on four seats of power protecting or watching over the holy city of Rajagriha. Interestingly this change also promotes moral and physical healing. The deaf have their ears open, hungry beings became satiated, and thirst was quenched. There is a sort of universal justice that occurs. There is a notable reference to the Ganges River, the spiritual center of Hinduism and comparison to "grains of sand" can't help but remind us of the promise of descendants to Abraham, a promise repeated by Saint Paul about the number who will come to believe in Christ.




Moving on, let's look at the image of heavenly Jerusalem. Here too we have an anonymous writer, though some say John imprisoned on Patmos, who has a heavenly vision. Pay attention to the details. This is the full chapter of Revelation 21.




Then I saw “a new heaven and a new earth,” for the first heaven and the first earth had passed away, and there was no longer any sea.  I saw the Holy City, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride beautifully dressed for her husband.  And I heard a loud voice from the throne saying, “Look! God’s dwelling place is now among the people, and he will dwell with them. They will be his people, and God himself will be with them and be their God.  ‘He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death’ or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away.”
He who was seated on the throne said, “I am making everything new!” Then he said, “Write this down, for these words are trustworthy and true.”
He said to me: “It is done. I am the Alpha and the Omega, the Beginning and the End. To the thirsty I will give water without cost from the spring of the water of life.  Those who are victorious will inherit all this, and I will be their God and they will be my children.  But the cowardly, the unbelieving, the vile, the murderers, the sexually immoral, those who practice magic arts, the idolaters and all liars—they will be consigned to the fiery lake of burning sulfur. This is the second death.”
One of the seven angels who had the seven bowls full of the seven last plagues came and said to me, “Come, I will show you the bride, the wife of the Lamb.”  And he carried me away in the Spirit to a mountain great and high, and showed me the Holy City, Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God.  It shone with the glory of God, and its brilliance was like that of a very precious jewel, like a jasper, clear as crystal.  It had a great, high wall with twelve gates, and with twelve angels at the gates. On the gates were written the names of the twelve tribes of Israel.  There were three gates on the east, three on the north, three on the south and three on the west.  The wall of the city had twelve foundations, and on them were the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb. The angel who talked with me had a measuring rod of gold to measure the city, its gates and its walls.  The city was laid out like a square, as long as it was wide. He measured the city with the rod and found it to be 12,000 stadia in length, and as wide and high as it is long.  The angel measured the wall using human measurement, and it was 144 cubits thick. The wall was made of jasper, and the city of pure gold, as pure as glass.  The foundations of the city walls were decorated with every kind of precious stone. The first foundation was jasper, the second sapphire, the third agate, the fourth emerald,  the fifth onyx, the sixth ruby, the seventh chrysolite, the eighth beryl, the ninth topaz, the tenth turquoise, the eleventh jacinth, and the twelfth amethyst. The twelve gates were twelve pearls, each gate made of a single pearl. The great street of the city was of gold, as pure as transparent glass. I did not see a temple in the city, because the Lord God Almighty and the Lamb are its temple.  The city does not need the sun or the moon to shine on it, for the glory of God gives it light, and the Lamb is its lamp. The nations will walk by its light, and the kings of the earth will bring their splendor into it.  On no day will its gates ever be shut, for there will be no night there.  The glory and honor of the nations will be brought into it.  Nothing impure will ever enter it, nor will anyone who does what is shameful or deceitful, but only those whose names are written in the Lamb’s book of life.



And just so we have our bases covered, let's not forget Matthew 19:28:

Jesus said to them, "Truly I tell you, at the renewal of all things, when the Son of Man sits on his glorious throne, you who have followed me will also sit on twelve thrones, judging the twelve tribes of Israel.


The Sutra of Golden Light also tells us that one disciple wishes to obtain knowledge to gain ascendancy over Trāyastriṃśa. This word in Sanskrit means "thirty three " and indicates the same number of  gods in Hinduism, but more generally in Buddhism, just the "pantheon of  gods."  So here too, there is this desire or promise to rule over all others. The thirty three were considered devas who were often entangled (for better or worse) in human affairs and so to have power over them could infer some sort of spiritual liberation as well.



There are a number of interesting comparisons to make. Perhaps the first is the level of detail to impress just how beautiful these cities are. There is something about precious stones and jewels that somehow speak to the heavenly, even among two cultures being completely separated by time and space. Just like the gold standard used on the international economic and currency markets, there is universal agreement that a heavenly place must be adorned in the most precious elements the human mind can conjure. While there is no more death and crying in Jerusalem, in Rajagriha, there are physical miracles. We have divine beings dwelling in the presence of their people. There is this strange notion that light and the image of light pervading from the city is not caused by the city per se, but comes directly from God in Jerusalem and Tathagata (the Buddha) in Rajagriha. Why is light important? In ancient cultures, light is more than a physical phenomenon. It also has spiritual meaning and is indicative of purity or holiness/separation.



Notable differences include a judgment of the good and wicked in Jerusalem, something that is lacking in Rajagriha. Also, as a technical point, not all of Rajagriha is transformed, only the house of Ruciraketu. But the importance of this may be negligible given the status of Rajagriha at the time.



Vulture's Peak, Rajagriha
What does all this mean? As any comparative scholar knows, ancient people were limited by their imaginations, just as we are about the future, and so we don't get images of machines in the Bible or towering skyscrapers or cellphones - we get an agricultural society with parables from that culture which we suppose contain universal truths that somehow translate into our own situations. But agriculture is just one truth of most cultures at this time. Water, fire, earth, wind - the elements become intimately part of the fabric of religion. The idea of precious stones are important as they dispel the realities of poverty and pronounce kingship and royalty, not necessarily true in today's culture where ownership has increased for more people than any other time in history. Food is also a heavenly promise. Jesus describes heaven as a banquet and the Buddha talks about hungry bellies being fed - an important promise considering many were living in poverty, disease, and were residents of subsistent living.



On a theological level, one might point to the Buddha's words (Buddhavacana). In the Lotus Sutra (a Chinese and Japanese Buddhist document), it is clear that the Buddha believes he came to the earth in different forms and that the dharma is spread in many forms, some less potent, and of those that do not teach the Four Noble Truths, less likely to succeed. This tension can also be found in the Christian scriptures where Jesus points to his love of Jerusalem but calls himself the way, truth, and the life. Or we can look at Saint Paul who in Romans 11 proclaims that Israel is the root of salvation and the Christians are but grafted in. The tension concerning the rise of Christ followers against the backdrop of the historical promises made to Israel is a palpable dilemma.

Wednesday, April 13, 2016

What is Absolute about Moral Absolutes?

Moral absolutism is often defined as a problem with ethical rigidity stemming from a particular interpretation of scripture. Unlike scriptural literalism, in which a literal interpretation that is broadly applied to the entire corpus of the Biblical witness does not exist due to the use of exaggeration or figurative speech, moral absolutism does exist, but often is a victim of ad hoc exceptions or philosophical problems, which makes its application as a broad-reaching approach more problematic.  



Moral absolutism of course seems good on the one hand. It creates a portrait of God whose work is perfect and irrepressible. It places the burden of faulty interpretations of scripture on the human being rather than problems of moral ambiguity on God. Moral absolutism is also an approach that is extracted from scripture rather than argued directly from scripture. It means that I can take a general position on a morally absolute interpretation of scripture rather than look for evidentiary warrant directly from scripture. For example, “Be perfect as I am perfect.”  Or in God there is no “shadow of turning.” Depending upon my understanding of libertarianism and deterministic thinking, I can do all sorts of things with these passages that do not necessarily impugn my approach to moral absolutes. I may, for example, examine how God “repented of his works” after destroying the world in Genesis, but I’m not obliged to read this as a flaw in his strategic planning. Perhaps I simply wanted to show the anthropocentric attention God gives to his creatures. Here,  we have removed the lens of moral absolutism entirely. We simply can blame ourselves for not knowing how to read the statement, instead of God for reneging on his perfect plans for creating a world that he did not anticipate would jeopardize the same through sin.

In other cases, however, the position of moral absolutism does not seem easily deflected. Moral absolutism is often bumped up against statements for which the commandment is complicated by other factors. Perhaps my friend asks me where his gun is. I learned last night that my friend wishes to take revenge on someone. I know where his gun is. When he comes to ask me, I have the opportunity to lie or to be honest. In fact, I hid it. Looking strictly at my situation using two prominent commandments, I find myself in a dilemma. If I lie, I break the commandment, but I might save the life of the person he is looking to harm. If I don’t lie and show him his gun, I do not break the commandment, however, now I might as well have broken another commandment as I will most likely become an accessory to murder.

May I offer a third option grounded in the academic theology of last century's ethical theorists: Moral absolutes are not about the commandment at all, but about my response.

The demand of the commandment is before me.  "Thou shalt not..." It is not the demand that requires obedience, but the demand that requires my response, which may or may not generate obedience. Obedience itself was a term used intentionally but with conscious redress against its more simplistic forms that throughout the history of Christian ethics affected its manifestation to "yes" and "no" reactions.



Think about it in terms of the nuances of law in the American judicial system. Laws in our country that allow us permission to self-defense differ from state to state and often involve a series of circumstances that can only be solved by carefully weighing the details.  There are certainly precedents, but ultimately anyone claiming self-defense as a motive for murder has to show any number of conditions have been satisfied, and even those details are often left to the determination by the jury or judge. What becomes absolute about a moral absolute? In this situation, it is not the law, but the response. One type of a response or any response?  If the command alone is a moral absolute, then there is little room for debating the details. It wouldn’t matter if a person struck me first, and I killed him. It wouldn’t matter if I didn’t see that person crossing the street. The moral absolute argument would dictate that the taking of a life is murder.

So is moral absolutism a term we should even use? Yes, but shifting the emphasis away from right action and to the act of action. What is absolute about a moral absolute is not the demand but my response. My response is an absolute in so far as it is a moral orientation to God - for better or worse. Given my contingent being, God does not need to demand anything of me in his commandment. As Kierkegaard writes, such a situation would undoubtedly make the commandment "higher than the individual." When, however, I acknowledge that even as far as the boundaries of my life extend, God is a necessity that draws in my contingency, my response becomes my trajectory. The content or context of my response is not what is in contention, but rather that I respond. When I am lukewarm, failing to respond, like the church in Revelation, I am “spit out of his mouth.”

Remember Abraham and God?

“I will destroy these cities because they have sinned.”

“Lord, please reconsider?”

“Remember Jacob and the angel?”

“I will not let you go until you bless me.”

Jacob and Abraham’s answers suggest that what is more important than God’s sovereign intervention is that his intervention always comes with the effect of soliciting my response, not a “right response.” After all, what confidence do we have in our flesh? writes Paul. The expediency of Jesus making his followers righteous means that the focus on the commandment’s rightness or wrongness is not as important as God loving the world to send his only Son.  This is the lesson of Luther, of Bonhoeffer, of Kierkegaard.  This is why these men started first with the human-divine relationship, before addressing the legal repercussions of the sin. This is why Luther could say beyond all other commandments, the greatest moral order was faith - the confidence of standing before God and saying your "yes" or "no."

Saturday, April 9, 2016

The Passion of Dietrich Bonhoeffer: A Creative Meditation on the Anniversary of his Death


It may be perfunctory that on the anniversary of the death of one of the most influential Western theologians of our time one is expected to talk about that fateful day. I would like instead to focus on the events leading up to that day first – a sort of passion narrative that follows a logic similar to that of Jesus’ own death.  Such an exercise will require some creative license to get us from the Via Dolorosa and the cross to the road that led to the Flossenbürg concentration camp and vice versa. This is one way we make tangible those events lost to time and space, and in accessing memory, which is a type of reconstruction of events, we project back into the story our own questions, answers, and expectations, creating the possibility of personal meaning where there is none, so that meaning becomes an existential possibility rather than merely a static imposition of the details.

Ash mound in Flossenbürg CC (what Eberhard Bethge referred to as a pyramid).
Dietrich Bonhoeffer's own ashes  were most likely deposited here along
with many others who were cremated on the premises after execution.
Today, April 9, 2016, marks seventy-one years since the execution of Dietrich Bonhoeffer by the Nazis on the charge of high treason.  Much of the information we have pertaining to the execution come from seasoned Bonhoeffer biographers like Eberhard Bethge, although others have contributed in recent years.

In his account of those days leading up to that execution, a number of men were tried for high treason and conspiratorial activities, stemming from work in the Abwehr and documents that were uncovered. Bonhoeffer’s name was found among the conspirators.

Upon receiving more evidence of conspiracy from SS General Ernst Kaltenbrunner, Adolf Hitler probably ordered him to liquidate Hans von Dohnanyi, Admiral Wilhelm Canaris, and his co-conspirators, which included Bonhoeffer.

At that same time the leading priests and elders were meeting at the residence of Caiaphas, the high priest, plotting how to capture Jesus secretly and kill him. “But not during the Passover celebration,” they agreed, “or the people may riot.” – Matthew 26:3-5

In the days closely leading up to Bonhoeffer’s execution, all who were to be tried as double agents, traitors, and resistors were present and accounted for with one exception. Bonhoeffer somehow had managed to slip between the cracks. The transport that was supposed to take him to Flossenbürg kept moving south.  Inside the prison, the night of April 5, 1945, the list of those to be executed was not adding up.  Accusations flew between prisoners who had been informed of the up-and-coming proceedings. “But you are Bonhoeffer!” At least three men were misidentified that evening, and it very well could have cost them their lives.

A servant girl noticed him in the firelight and began staring at him. Finally she said, “This man was one of Jesus’ followers! But Peter denied it. “Woman,” he said, “I don’t even know him! After a while someone else looked at him and said, “You must be one of them! No, man, I’m not!” Peter retorted. About an hour later someone else insisted, “This must be one of them, because he is a Galilean, too.” But Peter said, “Man, I don’t know what you are talking about.” And immediately, while he was still speaking, the rooster crowed.  – Luke 22: 56-60

Meanwhile, the convoy, known to us only by the label of the man leading the procession, an SS prison official by the name of Gogalla, would eventually stop in Schönberg.

They brought Jesus to the place Golgotha (which means ‘the place of the skull’) – Mark 15:22

Bonhoeffer was here, held up with friends from the convoy in a school. Though the men were suffering, they were able to support one another, to look out over a green mountain valley and see the countryside.

Jesus crossed the Kidron Valley with his disciples and entered a grove of olive trees.  Judas, the betrayer, knew this place, because Jesus had often gone there with his disciples. The leading priests and Pharisees had given Judas a contingent of Roman soldiers and Temple guards to accompany him. Now with blazing torches, lanterns, and weapons, they arrived at the olive grove. – John 18:1-3

Bonhoeffer had the opportunity to lead a hastily put together Mass that day among his fellow prisoners in a school room where they were resting and waiting for the next step in their extradition. Most of the men were Roman Catholics, with Vassily Kokorin being the only one who was an atheist of whom Bonhoeffer was fond and took the time earlier in the day to practice speaking Russian. When all had agreed to the Mass, Bonhoeffer decided to read from the prophet Isaiah.

The scroll of Isaiah the prophet was handed to him. He unrolled the scroll and found the place where this was written:

“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me,
for he has anointed me to bring Good News to the poor.
He has sent me to proclaim that captives will be released,
that the blind will see,
that the oppressed will be set free,
and that the time of the Lord’s favor has come.”

He rolled up the scroll, handed it back to the attendant, and sat down. All eyes in the synagogue looked at him intently. Then he began to speak to them. “The Scripture you’ve just heard has been fulfilled this very day!” – Luke 4: 17-21

Once the extradition was under way and Bonhoeffer was back in Flossenbürg, his trial was characteristically quick, as it was important to eliminate any trace of political prisoners to disguise the dubious practices of the Nazi death machine.  A farce of a trial transpired on April 8, 1945, with Dr. Otto Thorbeck pronouncing death on the conspirators, such were those who would destroy the German Reich and its people, who were expressly insubordinate to the will of the people and the national Zeitgeist. All were sentenced without the benefit of proper witnesses, testimonies, or documentation. The trial, for all intents and purposes, was an insubstantial shadow of justice.

Then the people who had arrested Jesus led him to the home of Caiaphas, the high priest, where the teachers of religious law and the elders had gathered. Meanwhile, Peter followed him at a distance and came to the high priest’s courtyard. He went in and sat with the guards and waited to see how it would all end. Inside, the leading priests and the entire high council were trying to find witnesses who would lie about Jesus, so they could put him to death. But even though they found many who agreed to give false witness, they could not use anyone’s testimony. Finally, two men came forward  who declared, “This man said, ‘I am able to destroy the Temple of God and rebuild it in three days.’” Then the high priest stood up and said to Jesus, “Well, aren’t you going to answer these charges? What do you have to say for yourself?” But Jesus remained silent. Then the high priest said to him, “I demand in the name of the living God—tell us if you are the Messiah, the Son of God.” Jesus replied, “You have said it. And in the future you will see the Son of Man seated in the place of power at God’s right hand and coming on the clouds of heaven.” Then the high priest tore his clothing to show his horror and said, “Blasphemy! Why do we need other witnesses? You have all heard his blasphemy. What is your verdict? Guilty!” they shouted. “He deserves to die!” – Matthew 26: 57-66

There was general anxiety among the high command that soon Germany would be overthrown and discussions about surrender were underway. There were attempts to spare certain political prisoners as a gesture of goodwill. Others, who could potential reveal damning evidence, needed to be eliminated. Though Bonhoeffer did not make this list, others like Martin Niemöller and Austrian Chancellor Kurt Alois Josef Johann Schushnigg, did, as those like Heinrich Himmler felt sparing such prisoners could save face with the Alliance and spare them the punishment of international law they rightly deserved. Those prisoners who were thought to be "political capital" were perhaps useful to exonerate anyone whose actions in judicial and leadership roles could be perceived as inhumane.

Meanwhile, the leading priests and the elders persuaded the crowd to ask for Barabbas to be released and for Jesus to be put to death. So the governor asked again, “Which of these two do you want me to release to you?” The crowd shouted back, “Barabbas!” Pilate responded, “Then what should I do with Jesus who is called the Messiah?” They shouted back, “Crucify him!” – Matthew 27: 20-22.


There are variations on the story of how Bonhoeffer died.

On the moment of his death Eberhard Bethge records the word of the camp doctor:  “I saw Pastor Bonhoeffer... kneeling on the floor praying fervently to God. I was most deeply moved by the way this lovable man prayed, so devout and so certain that God heard his prayer. At the place of execution, he again said a short prayer and then climbed the few steps to the gallows, brave and composed. His death ensued after a few seconds. In the almost fifty years that I worked as a doctor, I have hardly ever seen a man die so entirely submissive to the will of God.”

When the Roman officer who stood facing him saw how he had died, he exclaimed, “This man truly was the Son of God!” – Mark 15:39

However, these words and testimony have been challenged in more recent times. Noting a number of reasons, scholars today do not believe Bonhoeffer died with the resolve of a romanticized stoic, keeping his wits about him, in silence or serenity, concretizing his place in the annals of martyrdoms, but rather in pain and agony. Ferdinand Schlingensiepen’s version of what happened during those moments appears credible. He indicates that the individual in charge of executions was also given the nefarious task of keeping the hanged victims alive long enough for them to experience unnecessary torture and pain.  Such a sight clearly evokes the Jesus of Matthew rather than Luke:  

At noon, darkness fell across the whole land until three o’clock. 46 At about three o’clock, Jesus called out with a loud voice, “Eli, Eli, lema sabachthani?” which means “My God, my God, why have you abandoned me?” – Matthew 27: 45-46

And so we are faced with a Bonhoeffer who offers competing portraits as well - One who was stalwart in the face of death, or silent, or like many before him died in the fullness of pain and suffering.  In any case we are met by the man where the final words on his life were also challenged, who remains more controversial than we give him credit and yet remains part of our ritual veneration of men and women who braved harrowing circumstances to testify to Jesus.